Spatial application of a predictive wildlife occurrence model to assess alternative forest management scenarios in northern Arizona

Christopher T. Ray, Brett G Dickson, Thomas D Sisk, Steven E. Sesnie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Wildlife species of conservation concern can present forest managers with a particular challenge when habitat needs appear to be in contrast with other management objectives, particularly fuel reduction to reduce wildfire risk. Proposed actions can be opposed by stakeholders, delaying management activities until a resolution is met. In the southwestern USA, the primary goal of forest management is to reduce the risk of severe wildfire through forest restoration treatments. The USDA Forest Service has designated the northern goshawk (Accipiter gentilis) a management indicator species in this region. However, it has been difficult to achieve a common understanding of goshawk habitat needs among forest stakeholders. We combined two separate and complementary modeling approaches - a statistically based occurrence model and alternative forest treatment models - to yield predictions about forest management effects on the goshawk in ponderosa pine-dominated forests (Pinus ponderosa) on the Kaibab Plateau, Arizona. Forest treatment models were developed based on USDA Forest Service recommendations for goshawk habitat and post-treatment data from ecological restoration experiments, both of which were also components of forest treatment guidance from the Kaibab Forest Health Focus collaborative planning effort. All treatment alternatives resulted in a 22-26% reduction in estimated goshawk occurrence, but the declines were not uniform across the study area, varied by forest type, and were not as large as the effects of recent and severe wildfire (44% reduction in occurrence). Considering the controversial history of forest management with respect to the goshawk, it is prudent to interpret results from this study in the context of tradeoffs between wildfire risk reduction and wildlife habitat quality that can be effectively evaluated through science-based collaborative assessment and planning. While developed for a specific, high-profile species in the southwestern USA, the approach is applicable to many other species whose occurrence has been monitored over multiple years.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)117-126
Number of pages10
JournalForest Ecology and Management
Volume322
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 15 2014

Fingerprint

forest management
wildlife
wildfires
Accipiter gentilis
USDA Forest Service
Pinus ponderosa
wildfire
stakeholders
planning
habitats
forest health
forest restoration
wildlife habitats
ecological restoration
risk reduction
forest types
indicator species
coniferous forests
plateaus
managers

Keywords

  • Accipiter gentilis
  • Forest treatment simulation
  • Occurrence model
  • Pinus ponderosa
  • Restoration
  • Southwestern United States

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Forestry
  • Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law
  • Nature and Landscape Conservation

Cite this

Spatial application of a predictive wildlife occurrence model to assess alternative forest management scenarios in northern Arizona. / Ray, Christopher T.; Dickson, Brett G; Sisk, Thomas D; Sesnie, Steven E.

In: Forest Ecology and Management, Vol. 322, 15.06.2014, p. 117-126.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{c82556b305f94d3683a922235df1208e,
title = "Spatial application of a predictive wildlife occurrence model to assess alternative forest management scenarios in northern Arizona",
abstract = "Wildlife species of conservation concern can present forest managers with a particular challenge when habitat needs appear to be in contrast with other management objectives, particularly fuel reduction to reduce wildfire risk. Proposed actions can be opposed by stakeholders, delaying management activities until a resolution is met. In the southwestern USA, the primary goal of forest management is to reduce the risk of severe wildfire through forest restoration treatments. The USDA Forest Service has designated the northern goshawk (Accipiter gentilis) a management indicator species in this region. However, it has been difficult to achieve a common understanding of goshawk habitat needs among forest stakeholders. We combined two separate and complementary modeling approaches - a statistically based occurrence model and alternative forest treatment models - to yield predictions about forest management effects on the goshawk in ponderosa pine-dominated forests (Pinus ponderosa) on the Kaibab Plateau, Arizona. Forest treatment models were developed based on USDA Forest Service recommendations for goshawk habitat and post-treatment data from ecological restoration experiments, both of which were also components of forest treatment guidance from the Kaibab Forest Health Focus collaborative planning effort. All treatment alternatives resulted in a 22-26{\%} reduction in estimated goshawk occurrence, but the declines were not uniform across the study area, varied by forest type, and were not as large as the effects of recent and severe wildfire (44{\%} reduction in occurrence). Considering the controversial history of forest management with respect to the goshawk, it is prudent to interpret results from this study in the context of tradeoffs between wildfire risk reduction and wildlife habitat quality that can be effectively evaluated through science-based collaborative assessment and planning. While developed for a specific, high-profile species in the southwestern USA, the approach is applicable to many other species whose occurrence has been monitored over multiple years.",
keywords = "Accipiter gentilis, Forest treatment simulation, Occurrence model, Pinus ponderosa, Restoration, Southwestern United States",
author = "Ray, {Christopher T.} and Dickson, {Brett G} and Sisk, {Thomas D} and Sesnie, {Steven E.}",
year = "2014",
month = "6",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.foreco.2014.03.001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "322",
pages = "117--126",
journal = "Forest Ecology and Management",
issn = "0378-1127",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spatial application of a predictive wildlife occurrence model to assess alternative forest management scenarios in northern Arizona

AU - Ray, Christopher T.

AU - Dickson, Brett G

AU - Sisk, Thomas D

AU - Sesnie, Steven E.

PY - 2014/6/15

Y1 - 2014/6/15

N2 - Wildlife species of conservation concern can present forest managers with a particular challenge when habitat needs appear to be in contrast with other management objectives, particularly fuel reduction to reduce wildfire risk. Proposed actions can be opposed by stakeholders, delaying management activities until a resolution is met. In the southwestern USA, the primary goal of forest management is to reduce the risk of severe wildfire through forest restoration treatments. The USDA Forest Service has designated the northern goshawk (Accipiter gentilis) a management indicator species in this region. However, it has been difficult to achieve a common understanding of goshawk habitat needs among forest stakeholders. We combined two separate and complementary modeling approaches - a statistically based occurrence model and alternative forest treatment models - to yield predictions about forest management effects on the goshawk in ponderosa pine-dominated forests (Pinus ponderosa) on the Kaibab Plateau, Arizona. Forest treatment models were developed based on USDA Forest Service recommendations for goshawk habitat and post-treatment data from ecological restoration experiments, both of which were also components of forest treatment guidance from the Kaibab Forest Health Focus collaborative planning effort. All treatment alternatives resulted in a 22-26% reduction in estimated goshawk occurrence, but the declines were not uniform across the study area, varied by forest type, and were not as large as the effects of recent and severe wildfire (44% reduction in occurrence). Considering the controversial history of forest management with respect to the goshawk, it is prudent to interpret results from this study in the context of tradeoffs between wildfire risk reduction and wildlife habitat quality that can be effectively evaluated through science-based collaborative assessment and planning. While developed for a specific, high-profile species in the southwestern USA, the approach is applicable to many other species whose occurrence has been monitored over multiple years.

AB - Wildlife species of conservation concern can present forest managers with a particular challenge when habitat needs appear to be in contrast with other management objectives, particularly fuel reduction to reduce wildfire risk. Proposed actions can be opposed by stakeholders, delaying management activities until a resolution is met. In the southwestern USA, the primary goal of forest management is to reduce the risk of severe wildfire through forest restoration treatments. The USDA Forest Service has designated the northern goshawk (Accipiter gentilis) a management indicator species in this region. However, it has been difficult to achieve a common understanding of goshawk habitat needs among forest stakeholders. We combined two separate and complementary modeling approaches - a statistically based occurrence model and alternative forest treatment models - to yield predictions about forest management effects on the goshawk in ponderosa pine-dominated forests (Pinus ponderosa) on the Kaibab Plateau, Arizona. Forest treatment models were developed based on USDA Forest Service recommendations for goshawk habitat and post-treatment data from ecological restoration experiments, both of which were also components of forest treatment guidance from the Kaibab Forest Health Focus collaborative planning effort. All treatment alternatives resulted in a 22-26% reduction in estimated goshawk occurrence, but the declines were not uniform across the study area, varied by forest type, and were not as large as the effects of recent and severe wildfire (44% reduction in occurrence). Considering the controversial history of forest management with respect to the goshawk, it is prudent to interpret results from this study in the context of tradeoffs between wildfire risk reduction and wildlife habitat quality that can be effectively evaluated through science-based collaborative assessment and planning. While developed for a specific, high-profile species in the southwestern USA, the approach is applicable to many other species whose occurrence has been monitored over multiple years.

KW - Accipiter gentilis

KW - Forest treatment simulation

KW - Occurrence model

KW - Pinus ponderosa

KW - Restoration

KW - Southwestern United States

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84899920797&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84899920797&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.foreco.2014.03.001

DO - 10.1016/j.foreco.2014.03.001

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84899920797

VL - 322

SP - 117

EP - 126

JO - Forest Ecology and Management

JF - Forest Ecology and Management

SN - 0378-1127

ER -