Restoring plant species diversity and community composition in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem

Daniel C. Laughlin, Jonathan D. Bakker, Mark L. Daniels, Margaret M Moore, Cheryl A. Casey, Judith D. Springer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Monitoring of ecological restoration treatments often focuses on changes in community structure and function. We suggest that long-term changes in community composition also need to be explicitly considered when evaluating the success of restoration treatments. In 1992, we initiated an experiment in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem to evaluate responses to restoration treatments: (a) thinning the overstory vegetation ('thinning'), (b) thinning plus forest floor manipulation with periodic prescribed burning ('composite'), and (c) untreated 'control.' Treatments were further stratified by forest patch type: presettlement tree clumps (trees that established prior to the onset of fire exclusion in 1876), patches of retained postsettlement trees, patches where all postsettlement trees were removed, and remnant grass openings. Species richness did not differ among treatments for 10 years, but was highest in the composite treatment in 11th and 12th year after initial treatment. Community composition diverged among treatments 5 years after initial treatment, and compositional changes were greatest in the composite treatment. Species richness and composition differed among patch types prior to treatment. Remnant grass patches were the most diverse and presettlement patches were the least diverse. Following treatment, species richness in the postsettlement removed and retained patches, gradually approached levels found in remnant grass patches. Compositional differences among patch types changed a little by 2005. Species richness at the 2 m2 scale increased only where the overstory was thinned and the understory was burned. However, these changes may not be detectable for many years, and can vary temporally in response to events such as severe droughts. Nonnative species establishment may be reduced by scheduling longer burn intervals or by refraining from burning where fuel loads are not hazardous, though these options may hinder goals of increasing diversity. Restoring species diversity and community composition continues to be more difficult than restoring ecosystem structure and function.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)139-151
Number of pages13
JournalPlant Ecology
Volume197
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 2008

Fingerprint

Pinus ponderosa
community composition
species diversity
species richness
thinning
ecosystems
ecosystem
overstory
grass
thinning (plants)
grasses
prescribed burning
ecosystem structure
ecosystem function
long-term change
forest floor
retained trees
understory
community structure
ecological restoration

Keywords

  • Long-term studies
  • Permutational MANOVA
  • Pinus ponderosa
  • Prescribed fire
  • Species richness
  • Thinning
  • Understory

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Forestry
  • Plant Science
  • Ecology

Cite this

Restoring plant species diversity and community composition in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem. / Laughlin, Daniel C.; Bakker, Jonathan D.; Daniels, Mark L.; Moore, Margaret M; Casey, Cheryl A.; Springer, Judith D.

In: Plant Ecology, Vol. 197, No. 1, 07.2008, p. 139-151.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Laughlin, Daniel C. ; Bakker, Jonathan D. ; Daniels, Mark L. ; Moore, Margaret M ; Casey, Cheryl A. ; Springer, Judith D. / Restoring plant species diversity and community composition in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem. In: Plant Ecology. 2008 ; Vol. 197, No. 1. pp. 139-151.
@article{cd602e4f5791489c85f180c3293590e4,
title = "Restoring plant species diversity and community composition in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem",
abstract = "Monitoring of ecological restoration treatments often focuses on changes in community structure and function. We suggest that long-term changes in community composition also need to be explicitly considered when evaluating the success of restoration treatments. In 1992, we initiated an experiment in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem to evaluate responses to restoration treatments: (a) thinning the overstory vegetation ('thinning'), (b) thinning plus forest floor manipulation with periodic prescribed burning ('composite'), and (c) untreated 'control.' Treatments were further stratified by forest patch type: presettlement tree clumps (trees that established prior to the onset of fire exclusion in 1876), patches of retained postsettlement trees, patches where all postsettlement trees were removed, and remnant grass openings. Species richness did not differ among treatments for 10 years, but was highest in the composite treatment in 11th and 12th year after initial treatment. Community composition diverged among treatments 5 years after initial treatment, and compositional changes were greatest in the composite treatment. Species richness and composition differed among patch types prior to treatment. Remnant grass patches were the most diverse and presettlement patches were the least diverse. Following treatment, species richness in the postsettlement removed and retained patches, gradually approached levels found in remnant grass patches. Compositional differences among patch types changed a little by 2005. Species richness at the 2 m2 scale increased only where the overstory was thinned and the understory was burned. However, these changes may not be detectable for many years, and can vary temporally in response to events such as severe droughts. Nonnative species establishment may be reduced by scheduling longer burn intervals or by refraining from burning where fuel loads are not hazardous, though these options may hinder goals of increasing diversity. Restoring species diversity and community composition continues to be more difficult than restoring ecosystem structure and function.",
keywords = "Long-term studies, Permutational MANOVA, Pinus ponderosa, Prescribed fire, Species richness, Thinning, Understory",
author = "Laughlin, {Daniel C.} and Bakker, {Jonathan D.} and Daniels, {Mark L.} and Moore, {Margaret M} and Casey, {Cheryl A.} and Springer, {Judith D.}",
year = "2008",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1007/s11258-007-9367-9",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "197",
pages = "139--151",
journal = "Plant Ecology",
issn = "1385-0237",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Restoring plant species diversity and community composition in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem

AU - Laughlin, Daniel C.

AU - Bakker, Jonathan D.

AU - Daniels, Mark L.

AU - Moore, Margaret M

AU - Casey, Cheryl A.

AU - Springer, Judith D.

PY - 2008/7

Y1 - 2008/7

N2 - Monitoring of ecological restoration treatments often focuses on changes in community structure and function. We suggest that long-term changes in community composition also need to be explicitly considered when evaluating the success of restoration treatments. In 1992, we initiated an experiment in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem to evaluate responses to restoration treatments: (a) thinning the overstory vegetation ('thinning'), (b) thinning plus forest floor manipulation with periodic prescribed burning ('composite'), and (c) untreated 'control.' Treatments were further stratified by forest patch type: presettlement tree clumps (trees that established prior to the onset of fire exclusion in 1876), patches of retained postsettlement trees, patches where all postsettlement trees were removed, and remnant grass openings. Species richness did not differ among treatments for 10 years, but was highest in the composite treatment in 11th and 12th year after initial treatment. Community composition diverged among treatments 5 years after initial treatment, and compositional changes were greatest in the composite treatment. Species richness and composition differed among patch types prior to treatment. Remnant grass patches were the most diverse and presettlement patches were the least diverse. Following treatment, species richness in the postsettlement removed and retained patches, gradually approached levels found in remnant grass patches. Compositional differences among patch types changed a little by 2005. Species richness at the 2 m2 scale increased only where the overstory was thinned and the understory was burned. However, these changes may not be detectable for many years, and can vary temporally in response to events such as severe droughts. Nonnative species establishment may be reduced by scheduling longer burn intervals or by refraining from burning where fuel loads are not hazardous, though these options may hinder goals of increasing diversity. Restoring species diversity and community composition continues to be more difficult than restoring ecosystem structure and function.

AB - Monitoring of ecological restoration treatments often focuses on changes in community structure and function. We suggest that long-term changes in community composition also need to be explicitly considered when evaluating the success of restoration treatments. In 1992, we initiated an experiment in a ponderosa pine-bunchgrass ecosystem to evaluate responses to restoration treatments: (a) thinning the overstory vegetation ('thinning'), (b) thinning plus forest floor manipulation with periodic prescribed burning ('composite'), and (c) untreated 'control.' Treatments were further stratified by forest patch type: presettlement tree clumps (trees that established prior to the onset of fire exclusion in 1876), patches of retained postsettlement trees, patches where all postsettlement trees were removed, and remnant grass openings. Species richness did not differ among treatments for 10 years, but was highest in the composite treatment in 11th and 12th year after initial treatment. Community composition diverged among treatments 5 years after initial treatment, and compositional changes were greatest in the composite treatment. Species richness and composition differed among patch types prior to treatment. Remnant grass patches were the most diverse and presettlement patches were the least diverse. Following treatment, species richness in the postsettlement removed and retained patches, gradually approached levels found in remnant grass patches. Compositional differences among patch types changed a little by 2005. Species richness at the 2 m2 scale increased only where the overstory was thinned and the understory was burned. However, these changes may not be detectable for many years, and can vary temporally in response to events such as severe droughts. Nonnative species establishment may be reduced by scheduling longer burn intervals or by refraining from burning where fuel loads are not hazardous, though these options may hinder goals of increasing diversity. Restoring species diversity and community composition continues to be more difficult than restoring ecosystem structure and function.

KW - Long-term studies

KW - Permutational MANOVA

KW - Pinus ponderosa

KW - Prescribed fire

KW - Species richness

KW - Thinning

KW - Understory

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=44349088329&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=44349088329&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11258-007-9367-9

DO - 10.1007/s11258-007-9367-9

M3 - Article

VL - 197

SP - 139

EP - 151

JO - Plant Ecology

JF - Plant Ecology

SN - 1385-0237

IS - 1

ER -