Quantifying the multi-scale response of avifauna to prescribed fire experiments in the southwest United States

Brett G Dickson, Barry R. Noon, Curtis H. Flather, Stephanie Jentsch, William M. Block

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Landscape-scale disturbance events, including ecological restoration and fuel reduction activities, can modify habitat and affect relationships between species and their environment. To reduce the risk of uncharacteristic stand-replacing fires in the southwestern United States, land managers are implementing restoration and fuels treatments (e.g., mechanical thinning, prescribed fire) in progressively larger stands of dry, lower elevation ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) forest. We used a Before-After/Control-Impact experimental design to quantify the multi-scale response of avifauna to large (;250-400 ha) prescribed fire treatments on four sites in Arizona and New Mexico dominated by ponderosa pine. Using distance sampling and an information-theoretic approach, we estimated changes in density for 14 bird species detected before (May-June 2002-2003) and after (May-June 2004-2005) prescribed fire treatments. We observed few site-level differences in pre- and posttreatment density, and no species responded strongly to treatment on all four sites. Pointlevel spatial models of individual species response to treatment, habitat variables, and fire severity revealed ecological relationships that were more easily interpreted. At this scale, pretreatment forest structure and patch characteristics were important predictors of posttreatment differences in bird species density. Five species (Pygmy Nuthatch [Sitta pygmaea], Western Bluebird [Sialia mexicana], Steller's Jay [Cyanocitta stelleri ], American Robin [Turdus migratorius], and Hairy Woodpecker [Picoides villosus]) exhibited a strong treatment response, and two of these species (American Robin and Hairy Woodpecker) could be associated with meaningful fire severity response functions. The avifaunal response patterns that we observed were not always consistent with those reported by more common studies of wildland fire events. Our results suggest that, in the short term, the distribution and abundance of common members of the breeding bird community in Southwestern ponderosa pine forests appear to be tolerant of low- to moderate-intensity prescribed fire treatments at multiple spatial scales and across multiple geographic locations.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)608-621
Number of pages14
JournalEcological Applications
Volume19
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 2009

Fingerprint

avifauna
experiment
habitat
experimental design
thinning
disturbance
sampling

Keywords

  • BACI design
  • Birds
  • Density
  • Distance sampling
  • Fire severity
  • Forest structure
  • Fuel reduction treatments
  • Model selection
  • Ponderosa pine
  • Prescribed fire
  • Restoration
  • Scale

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Quantifying the multi-scale response of avifauna to prescribed fire experiments in the southwest United States. / Dickson, Brett G; Noon, Barry R.; Flather, Curtis H.; Jentsch, Stephanie; Block, William M.

In: Ecological Applications, Vol. 19, No. 3, 04.2009, p. 608-621.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dickson, Brett G ; Noon, Barry R. ; Flather, Curtis H. ; Jentsch, Stephanie ; Block, William M. / Quantifying the multi-scale response of avifauna to prescribed fire experiments in the southwest United States. In: Ecological Applications. 2009 ; Vol. 19, No. 3. pp. 608-621.
@article{a5c843c9766b496b9fb4f86a41b8e59f,
title = "Quantifying the multi-scale response of avifauna to prescribed fire experiments in the southwest United States",
abstract = "Landscape-scale disturbance events, including ecological restoration and fuel reduction activities, can modify habitat and affect relationships between species and their environment. To reduce the risk of uncharacteristic stand-replacing fires in the southwestern United States, land managers are implementing restoration and fuels treatments (e.g., mechanical thinning, prescribed fire) in progressively larger stands of dry, lower elevation ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) forest. We used a Before-After/Control-Impact experimental design to quantify the multi-scale response of avifauna to large (;250-400 ha) prescribed fire treatments on four sites in Arizona and New Mexico dominated by ponderosa pine. Using distance sampling and an information-theoretic approach, we estimated changes in density for 14 bird species detected before (May-June 2002-2003) and after (May-June 2004-2005) prescribed fire treatments. We observed few site-level differences in pre- and posttreatment density, and no species responded strongly to treatment on all four sites. Pointlevel spatial models of individual species response to treatment, habitat variables, and fire severity revealed ecological relationships that were more easily interpreted. At this scale, pretreatment forest structure and patch characteristics were important predictors of posttreatment differences in bird species density. Five species (Pygmy Nuthatch [Sitta pygmaea], Western Bluebird [Sialia mexicana], Steller's Jay [Cyanocitta stelleri ], American Robin [Turdus migratorius], and Hairy Woodpecker [Picoides villosus]) exhibited a strong treatment response, and two of these species (American Robin and Hairy Woodpecker) could be associated with meaningful fire severity response functions. The avifaunal response patterns that we observed were not always consistent with those reported by more common studies of wildland fire events. Our results suggest that, in the short term, the distribution and abundance of common members of the breeding bird community in Southwestern ponderosa pine forests appear to be tolerant of low- to moderate-intensity prescribed fire treatments at multiple spatial scales and across multiple geographic locations.",
keywords = "BACI design, Birds, Density, Distance sampling, Fire severity, Forest structure, Fuel reduction treatments, Model selection, Ponderosa pine, Prescribed fire, Restoration, Scale",
author = "Dickson, {Brett G} and Noon, {Barry R.} and Flather, {Curtis H.} and Stephanie Jentsch and Block, {William M.}",
year = "2009",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1890/08-0905.1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "19",
pages = "608--621",
journal = "Ecological Appplications",
issn = "1051-0761",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Quantifying the multi-scale response of avifauna to prescribed fire experiments in the southwest United States

AU - Dickson, Brett G

AU - Noon, Barry R.

AU - Flather, Curtis H.

AU - Jentsch, Stephanie

AU - Block, William M.

PY - 2009/4

Y1 - 2009/4

N2 - Landscape-scale disturbance events, including ecological restoration and fuel reduction activities, can modify habitat and affect relationships between species and their environment. To reduce the risk of uncharacteristic stand-replacing fires in the southwestern United States, land managers are implementing restoration and fuels treatments (e.g., mechanical thinning, prescribed fire) in progressively larger stands of dry, lower elevation ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) forest. We used a Before-After/Control-Impact experimental design to quantify the multi-scale response of avifauna to large (;250-400 ha) prescribed fire treatments on four sites in Arizona and New Mexico dominated by ponderosa pine. Using distance sampling and an information-theoretic approach, we estimated changes in density for 14 bird species detected before (May-June 2002-2003) and after (May-June 2004-2005) prescribed fire treatments. We observed few site-level differences in pre- and posttreatment density, and no species responded strongly to treatment on all four sites. Pointlevel spatial models of individual species response to treatment, habitat variables, and fire severity revealed ecological relationships that were more easily interpreted. At this scale, pretreatment forest structure and patch characteristics were important predictors of posttreatment differences in bird species density. Five species (Pygmy Nuthatch [Sitta pygmaea], Western Bluebird [Sialia mexicana], Steller's Jay [Cyanocitta stelleri ], American Robin [Turdus migratorius], and Hairy Woodpecker [Picoides villosus]) exhibited a strong treatment response, and two of these species (American Robin and Hairy Woodpecker) could be associated with meaningful fire severity response functions. The avifaunal response patterns that we observed were not always consistent with those reported by more common studies of wildland fire events. Our results suggest that, in the short term, the distribution and abundance of common members of the breeding bird community in Southwestern ponderosa pine forests appear to be tolerant of low- to moderate-intensity prescribed fire treatments at multiple spatial scales and across multiple geographic locations.

AB - Landscape-scale disturbance events, including ecological restoration and fuel reduction activities, can modify habitat and affect relationships between species and their environment. To reduce the risk of uncharacteristic stand-replacing fires in the southwestern United States, land managers are implementing restoration and fuels treatments (e.g., mechanical thinning, prescribed fire) in progressively larger stands of dry, lower elevation ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) forest. We used a Before-After/Control-Impact experimental design to quantify the multi-scale response of avifauna to large (;250-400 ha) prescribed fire treatments on four sites in Arizona and New Mexico dominated by ponderosa pine. Using distance sampling and an information-theoretic approach, we estimated changes in density for 14 bird species detected before (May-June 2002-2003) and after (May-June 2004-2005) prescribed fire treatments. We observed few site-level differences in pre- and posttreatment density, and no species responded strongly to treatment on all four sites. Pointlevel spatial models of individual species response to treatment, habitat variables, and fire severity revealed ecological relationships that were more easily interpreted. At this scale, pretreatment forest structure and patch characteristics were important predictors of posttreatment differences in bird species density. Five species (Pygmy Nuthatch [Sitta pygmaea], Western Bluebird [Sialia mexicana], Steller's Jay [Cyanocitta stelleri ], American Robin [Turdus migratorius], and Hairy Woodpecker [Picoides villosus]) exhibited a strong treatment response, and two of these species (American Robin and Hairy Woodpecker) could be associated with meaningful fire severity response functions. The avifaunal response patterns that we observed were not always consistent with those reported by more common studies of wildland fire events. Our results suggest that, in the short term, the distribution and abundance of common members of the breeding bird community in Southwestern ponderosa pine forests appear to be tolerant of low- to moderate-intensity prescribed fire treatments at multiple spatial scales and across multiple geographic locations.

KW - BACI design

KW - Birds

KW - Density

KW - Distance sampling

KW - Fire severity

KW - Forest structure

KW - Fuel reduction treatments

KW - Model selection

KW - Ponderosa pine

KW - Prescribed fire

KW - Restoration

KW - Scale

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=65349099353&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=65349099353&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1890/08-0905.1

DO - 10.1890/08-0905.1

M3 - Article

VL - 19

SP - 608

EP - 621

JO - Ecological Appplications

JF - Ecological Appplications

SN - 1051-0761

IS - 3

ER -