Plant community variability in ponderosa pine forest has implications for reference conditions

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

28 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Ponderosa pine plant community and forest structure were compared among three stands in Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona: one stand had 120 years of artificial fire exclusion (NOBURN) and the other two nearby stands had been frequently burned (BURN-E and BURN-W). These forests are valuable places to gauge anthropogenic changes associated with European settlement, due to their land history of limited livestock grazing and no logging. Precipitation varied greatly between sampling years (260 mm in 2000, 505 mm in 2001). Tree density was significantly higher at NOBURN (1424 trees ha -1) with significantly higher rotten coarse woody debris (23.2 Mg ha -1) and duff depth (4.3 cm) than at the burned sites, as expected in the absence of fire. Although species richness was not significantly different among sites (48-89 species), richness differed significantly by year. Shannon's index of diversity increased by approximately 10% from the dry year to the wet year on all sites. Community composition and plant cover at NOBURN differed significantly from the two burned sites in both years in non-metric multidimensional scaling ordinations. Increasing duff depth was related to decreased plant cover. Two of the three dominant species were different at the fire-excluded site compared to the burned sites. We conclude that although plant community structure was related to fire history, environmental stress and within-stand variability were also important drivers. We suggest selecting reference sites in close proximity to the site to be restored and using a multi-scale, multi-year, multi-site approach to measure reference conditions in ponderosa pine.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)101-111
Number of pages11
JournalNatural Areas Journal
Volume24
Issue number2
StatePublished - Apr 2004

Fingerprint

Pinus ponderosa
coniferous forests
plant community
plant communities
ground cover plants
species richness
fire history
coarse woody debris
environmental stress
ordination
species diversity
canyon
community composition
gauge
livestock
canyons
national park
community structure
grazing
gauges

Keywords

  • Arizona
  • Ecological restoration
  • Fire ecology
  • Grand Canyon
  • Kaibab Plateau

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Forestry
  • Ecology

Cite this

Plant community variability in ponderosa pine forest has implications for reference conditions. / Gildar, C. N.; Fulé, P. Z.; Covington, W. W.

In: Natural Areas Journal, Vol. 24, No. 2, 04.2004, p. 101-111.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a829ad469dca4a53be8116c874d3d372,
title = "Plant community variability in ponderosa pine forest has implications for reference conditions",
abstract = "Ponderosa pine plant community and forest structure were compared among three stands in Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona: one stand had 120 years of artificial fire exclusion (NOBURN) and the other two nearby stands had been frequently burned (BURN-E and BURN-W). These forests are valuable places to gauge anthropogenic changes associated with European settlement, due to their land history of limited livestock grazing and no logging. Precipitation varied greatly between sampling years (260 mm in 2000, 505 mm in 2001). Tree density was significantly higher at NOBURN (1424 trees ha -1) with significantly higher rotten coarse woody debris (23.2 Mg ha -1) and duff depth (4.3 cm) than at the burned sites, as expected in the absence of fire. Although species richness was not significantly different among sites (48-89 species), richness differed significantly by year. Shannon's index of diversity increased by approximately 10{\%} from the dry year to the wet year on all sites. Community composition and plant cover at NOBURN differed significantly from the two burned sites in both years in non-metric multidimensional scaling ordinations. Increasing duff depth was related to decreased plant cover. Two of the three dominant species were different at the fire-excluded site compared to the burned sites. We conclude that although plant community structure was related to fire history, environmental stress and within-stand variability were also important drivers. We suggest selecting reference sites in close proximity to the site to be restored and using a multi-scale, multi-year, multi-site approach to measure reference conditions in ponderosa pine.",
keywords = "Arizona, Ecological restoration, Fire ecology, Grand Canyon, Kaibab Plateau",
author = "Gildar, {C. N.} and Ful{\'e}, {P. Z.} and Covington, {W. W.}",
year = "2004",
month = "4",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "24",
pages = "101--111",
journal = "Natural Areas Journal",
issn = "0885-8608",
publisher = "Natural Areas Association",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Plant community variability in ponderosa pine forest has implications for reference conditions

AU - Gildar, C. N.

AU - Fulé, P. Z.

AU - Covington, W. W.

PY - 2004/4

Y1 - 2004/4

N2 - Ponderosa pine plant community and forest structure were compared among three stands in Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona: one stand had 120 years of artificial fire exclusion (NOBURN) and the other two nearby stands had been frequently burned (BURN-E and BURN-W). These forests are valuable places to gauge anthropogenic changes associated with European settlement, due to their land history of limited livestock grazing and no logging. Precipitation varied greatly between sampling years (260 mm in 2000, 505 mm in 2001). Tree density was significantly higher at NOBURN (1424 trees ha -1) with significantly higher rotten coarse woody debris (23.2 Mg ha -1) and duff depth (4.3 cm) than at the burned sites, as expected in the absence of fire. Although species richness was not significantly different among sites (48-89 species), richness differed significantly by year. Shannon's index of diversity increased by approximately 10% from the dry year to the wet year on all sites. Community composition and plant cover at NOBURN differed significantly from the two burned sites in both years in non-metric multidimensional scaling ordinations. Increasing duff depth was related to decreased plant cover. Two of the three dominant species were different at the fire-excluded site compared to the burned sites. We conclude that although plant community structure was related to fire history, environmental stress and within-stand variability were also important drivers. We suggest selecting reference sites in close proximity to the site to be restored and using a multi-scale, multi-year, multi-site approach to measure reference conditions in ponderosa pine.

AB - Ponderosa pine plant community and forest structure were compared among three stands in Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona: one stand had 120 years of artificial fire exclusion (NOBURN) and the other two nearby stands had been frequently burned (BURN-E and BURN-W). These forests are valuable places to gauge anthropogenic changes associated with European settlement, due to their land history of limited livestock grazing and no logging. Precipitation varied greatly between sampling years (260 mm in 2000, 505 mm in 2001). Tree density was significantly higher at NOBURN (1424 trees ha -1) with significantly higher rotten coarse woody debris (23.2 Mg ha -1) and duff depth (4.3 cm) than at the burned sites, as expected in the absence of fire. Although species richness was not significantly different among sites (48-89 species), richness differed significantly by year. Shannon's index of diversity increased by approximately 10% from the dry year to the wet year on all sites. Community composition and plant cover at NOBURN differed significantly from the two burned sites in both years in non-metric multidimensional scaling ordinations. Increasing duff depth was related to decreased plant cover. Two of the three dominant species were different at the fire-excluded site compared to the burned sites. We conclude that although plant community structure was related to fire history, environmental stress and within-stand variability were also important drivers. We suggest selecting reference sites in close proximity to the site to be restored and using a multi-scale, multi-year, multi-site approach to measure reference conditions in ponderosa pine.

KW - Arizona

KW - Ecological restoration

KW - Fire ecology

KW - Grand Canyon

KW - Kaibab Plateau

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=4444309412&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=4444309412&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:4444309412

VL - 24

SP - 101

EP - 111

JO - Natural Areas Journal

JF - Natural Areas Journal

SN - 0885-8608

IS - 2

ER -