Model selection for a subterranean trophic cascade

Root-feeding caterpillars and entomopathogenic nematodes

D. R. Strong, Amy V Whipple, A. L. Child, B. Dennis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

76 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Conjecture abounds while evidence is limited concerning indirect protection afforded plants by carnivorous predators in terrestrial ecosystems, apropos of the Hairston-Smith-Slobodkin (HSS) hypothesis. We conducted a field experiment with a suspected trophic cascade. Could an entomopathogenic nematode protect bush lupine by killing rootfeeding ghost moth caterpillars? The experiment measured survival of lupine seedlings as a function of density of hatchling ghost moth caterpillars in rhizospheres with or without the entomopathogenic nematode. We modeled lupine survival with a hierarchical family of 'one-hit dose response' models to interpret the results of the experiment. We obtained maximum likelihood estimates of parameters and selected the best-fitting model using the Schwarz Information Criterion (SIC). The best model fit the data closely, and SIC model selection was consistent with classical likelihood ratio test results of models nested in the one-hit family. A parallel analysis performed upon a logistic family of models yielded results of poorer fit but largely consistent with results of the one-hit analysis. Finally, we compared our model-centered approach with the conventional methods-centered approach of logistic regression in statistical packages. While these packages give correct calculations, the implications of hypothesis tests are ecologically obscure in the absence of the explicit representation of models and their hierarchical relationships. For understanding ecological data, building an explicit statistical model of the process and testing parameters can be more informative than accepting the implicit model and testing variables in canned statistical packages. The ecological implications were that seedling survival decreased exponentially with increasing densities of root-feeding caterpillars, and the entomopathogenic nematode virtually canceled the negative effect of this herbivore upon seedling survival. However, the significance to the broader community of this trophic cascade remains to be demonstrated. This cascade is a module or vignette within the greater food web, and additional interactions affect its influence: intraguild predation by nematode predators, apparent competition from other herbivores of lupine (each with its own natural enemies), and even more complicated interactions through competing plant species all come into play. As well, genetic variation of both the lupine and ghost moth caterpillars affects these interactions. Evidence does not support the inference that protection from ghost moth caterpillars by the entomopathogenic nematode is key to the 'green' world of bush lupine.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)2750-2761
Number of pages12
JournalEcology
Volume80
Issue number8
StatePublished - Dec 1999
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

trophic cascade
entomopathogenic nematodes
caterpillar
nematode
insect larvae
Hepialus humuli
Lupinus
moth
Lupinus arboreus
seedling
seedlings
herbivores
herbivore
logistics
testing
predators
predator
apparent competition
intraguild predation
statistical models

Keywords

  • Akaike information criterion
  • Binary data
  • Entomopathogenic nematode
  • Indirect interaction
  • Natural enemy
  • One-hit dose-response
  • Schwarz information criterion
  • Statistical models
  • Subterranean herbivory

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Model selection for a subterranean trophic cascade : Root-feeding caterpillars and entomopathogenic nematodes. / Strong, D. R.; Whipple, Amy V; Child, A. L.; Dennis, B.

In: Ecology, Vol. 80, No. 8, 12.1999, p. 2750-2761.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Strong, D. R. ; Whipple, Amy V ; Child, A. L. ; Dennis, B. / Model selection for a subterranean trophic cascade : Root-feeding caterpillars and entomopathogenic nematodes. In: Ecology. 1999 ; Vol. 80, No. 8. pp. 2750-2761.
@article{d534d5633cf74de0ace2c643ba49463d,
title = "Model selection for a subterranean trophic cascade: Root-feeding caterpillars and entomopathogenic nematodes",
abstract = "Conjecture abounds while evidence is limited concerning indirect protection afforded plants by carnivorous predators in terrestrial ecosystems, apropos of the Hairston-Smith-Slobodkin (HSS) hypothesis. We conducted a field experiment with a suspected trophic cascade. Could an entomopathogenic nematode protect bush lupine by killing rootfeeding ghost moth caterpillars? The experiment measured survival of lupine seedlings as a function of density of hatchling ghost moth caterpillars in rhizospheres with or without the entomopathogenic nematode. We modeled lupine survival with a hierarchical family of 'one-hit dose response' models to interpret the results of the experiment. We obtained maximum likelihood estimates of parameters and selected the best-fitting model using the Schwarz Information Criterion (SIC). The best model fit the data closely, and SIC model selection was consistent with classical likelihood ratio test results of models nested in the one-hit family. A parallel analysis performed upon a logistic family of models yielded results of poorer fit but largely consistent with results of the one-hit analysis. Finally, we compared our model-centered approach with the conventional methods-centered approach of logistic regression in statistical packages. While these packages give correct calculations, the implications of hypothesis tests are ecologically obscure in the absence of the explicit representation of models and their hierarchical relationships. For understanding ecological data, building an explicit statistical model of the process and testing parameters can be more informative than accepting the implicit model and testing variables in canned statistical packages. The ecological implications were that seedling survival decreased exponentially with increasing densities of root-feeding caterpillars, and the entomopathogenic nematode virtually canceled the negative effect of this herbivore upon seedling survival. However, the significance to the broader community of this trophic cascade remains to be demonstrated. This cascade is a module or vignette within the greater food web, and additional interactions affect its influence: intraguild predation by nematode predators, apparent competition from other herbivores of lupine (each with its own natural enemies), and even more complicated interactions through competing plant species all come into play. As well, genetic variation of both the lupine and ghost moth caterpillars affects these interactions. Evidence does not support the inference that protection from ghost moth caterpillars by the entomopathogenic nematode is key to the 'green' world of bush lupine.",
keywords = "Akaike information criterion, Binary data, Entomopathogenic nematode, Indirect interaction, Natural enemy, One-hit dose-response, Schwarz information criterion, Statistical models, Subterranean herbivory",
author = "Strong, {D. R.} and Whipple, {Amy V} and Child, {A. L.} and B. Dennis",
year = "1999",
month = "12",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "80",
pages = "2750--2761",
journal = "Ecology",
issn = "0012-9658",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Model selection for a subterranean trophic cascade

T2 - Root-feeding caterpillars and entomopathogenic nematodes

AU - Strong, D. R.

AU - Whipple, Amy V

AU - Child, A. L.

AU - Dennis, B.

PY - 1999/12

Y1 - 1999/12

N2 - Conjecture abounds while evidence is limited concerning indirect protection afforded plants by carnivorous predators in terrestrial ecosystems, apropos of the Hairston-Smith-Slobodkin (HSS) hypothesis. We conducted a field experiment with a suspected trophic cascade. Could an entomopathogenic nematode protect bush lupine by killing rootfeeding ghost moth caterpillars? The experiment measured survival of lupine seedlings as a function of density of hatchling ghost moth caterpillars in rhizospheres with or without the entomopathogenic nematode. We modeled lupine survival with a hierarchical family of 'one-hit dose response' models to interpret the results of the experiment. We obtained maximum likelihood estimates of parameters and selected the best-fitting model using the Schwarz Information Criterion (SIC). The best model fit the data closely, and SIC model selection was consistent with classical likelihood ratio test results of models nested in the one-hit family. A parallel analysis performed upon a logistic family of models yielded results of poorer fit but largely consistent with results of the one-hit analysis. Finally, we compared our model-centered approach with the conventional methods-centered approach of logistic regression in statistical packages. While these packages give correct calculations, the implications of hypothesis tests are ecologically obscure in the absence of the explicit representation of models and their hierarchical relationships. For understanding ecological data, building an explicit statistical model of the process and testing parameters can be more informative than accepting the implicit model and testing variables in canned statistical packages. The ecological implications were that seedling survival decreased exponentially with increasing densities of root-feeding caterpillars, and the entomopathogenic nematode virtually canceled the negative effect of this herbivore upon seedling survival. However, the significance to the broader community of this trophic cascade remains to be demonstrated. This cascade is a module or vignette within the greater food web, and additional interactions affect its influence: intraguild predation by nematode predators, apparent competition from other herbivores of lupine (each with its own natural enemies), and even more complicated interactions through competing plant species all come into play. As well, genetic variation of both the lupine and ghost moth caterpillars affects these interactions. Evidence does not support the inference that protection from ghost moth caterpillars by the entomopathogenic nematode is key to the 'green' world of bush lupine.

AB - Conjecture abounds while evidence is limited concerning indirect protection afforded plants by carnivorous predators in terrestrial ecosystems, apropos of the Hairston-Smith-Slobodkin (HSS) hypothesis. We conducted a field experiment with a suspected trophic cascade. Could an entomopathogenic nematode protect bush lupine by killing rootfeeding ghost moth caterpillars? The experiment measured survival of lupine seedlings as a function of density of hatchling ghost moth caterpillars in rhizospheres with or without the entomopathogenic nematode. We modeled lupine survival with a hierarchical family of 'one-hit dose response' models to interpret the results of the experiment. We obtained maximum likelihood estimates of parameters and selected the best-fitting model using the Schwarz Information Criterion (SIC). The best model fit the data closely, and SIC model selection was consistent with classical likelihood ratio test results of models nested in the one-hit family. A parallel analysis performed upon a logistic family of models yielded results of poorer fit but largely consistent with results of the one-hit analysis. Finally, we compared our model-centered approach with the conventional methods-centered approach of logistic regression in statistical packages. While these packages give correct calculations, the implications of hypothesis tests are ecologically obscure in the absence of the explicit representation of models and their hierarchical relationships. For understanding ecological data, building an explicit statistical model of the process and testing parameters can be more informative than accepting the implicit model and testing variables in canned statistical packages. The ecological implications were that seedling survival decreased exponentially with increasing densities of root-feeding caterpillars, and the entomopathogenic nematode virtually canceled the negative effect of this herbivore upon seedling survival. However, the significance to the broader community of this trophic cascade remains to be demonstrated. This cascade is a module or vignette within the greater food web, and additional interactions affect its influence: intraguild predation by nematode predators, apparent competition from other herbivores of lupine (each with its own natural enemies), and even more complicated interactions through competing plant species all come into play. As well, genetic variation of both the lupine and ghost moth caterpillars affects these interactions. Evidence does not support the inference that protection from ghost moth caterpillars by the entomopathogenic nematode is key to the 'green' world of bush lupine.

KW - Akaike information criterion

KW - Binary data

KW - Entomopathogenic nematode

KW - Indirect interaction

KW - Natural enemy

KW - One-hit dose-response

KW - Schwarz information criterion

KW - Statistical models

KW - Subterranean herbivory

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0033429217&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0033429217&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 80

SP - 2750

EP - 2761

JO - Ecology

JF - Ecology

SN - 0012-9658

IS - 8

ER -