"Minimal-Impact" restoration treatments have limited effects on forest structure and fuels at Grand Canyon, USA

Peter Z Fule, Wallace W Covington, Michael T. Stoddard, Don Bertolette

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Restoration treatments were tested on the South Rim (ponderosa pine) and North Rim (mixed conifer) of Grand Canyon National Park, never-harvested forests where the historically frequent surface regime was interrupted in the late 19th century. Treatments were designed for "minimal impact"by limiting the size of trees to be thinned and minimizing mechanical equipment. Treatments included (1) thinning of small trees (diameter ≤ 12.7 cm) and prescribed fire; (2) thinning of small trees located close to large old trees and prescribed fire; (3) prescribed fire only; and (4) control. On the South Rim, density declined by 23-45% but basal area only by 9-14%. On the North Rim, density was reduced 32-68% and basal area declined 18-31%. Declines of 5-8% were observed in these same variables in the controls. Surface fuels were significantly reduced in all burned treatments (70-84% reduction in forest floor, 66-76% reduction in woody debris). However, canopy cover was nearly unchanged, and canopy fuel loads were not significantly reduced, although canopy base heights increased. The experiment accomplished the goal of minimally impacting the forest ecosystem but the effects of small-tree thinning plus burning were nearly indistinguishable from those of burning alone. All the treated units were left with modest gain in resistance to severe wildfires but in conditions still far removed from prefire-exclusion conditions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)357-368
Number of pages12
JournalRestoration Ecology
Volume14
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 2006

Fingerprint

canyons
canyon
prescribed burning
thinning (plants)
thinning
basal area
canopy
fuels (fire ecology)
Pinus ponderosa
wildfires
forest litter
tree and stand measurements
woody debris
forest ecosystems
conifers
national parks
forest floor
wildfire
forest ecosystem
coniferous tree

Keywords

  • Ecological restoration
  • Fire
  • Fuel reduction
  • Southwest

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

"Minimal-Impact" restoration treatments have limited effects on forest structure and fuels at Grand Canyon, USA. / Fule, Peter Z; Covington, Wallace W; Stoddard, Michael T.; Bertolette, Don.

In: Restoration Ecology, Vol. 14, No. 3, 09.2006, p. 357-368.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f532251cbf674af5bd52bd99513325bb,
title = "{"}Minimal-Impact{"} restoration treatments have limited effects on forest structure and fuels at Grand Canyon, USA",
abstract = "Restoration treatments were tested on the South Rim (ponderosa pine) and North Rim (mixed conifer) of Grand Canyon National Park, never-harvested forests where the historically frequent surface regime was interrupted in the late 19th century. Treatments were designed for {"}minimal impact{"}by limiting the size of trees to be thinned and minimizing mechanical equipment. Treatments included (1) thinning of small trees (diameter ≤ 12.7 cm) and prescribed fire; (2) thinning of small trees located close to large old trees and prescribed fire; (3) prescribed fire only; and (4) control. On the South Rim, density declined by 23-45{\%} but basal area only by 9-14{\%}. On the North Rim, density was reduced 32-68{\%} and basal area declined 18-31{\%}. Declines of 5-8{\%} were observed in these same variables in the controls. Surface fuels were significantly reduced in all burned treatments (70-84{\%} reduction in forest floor, 66-76{\%} reduction in woody debris). However, canopy cover was nearly unchanged, and canopy fuel loads were not significantly reduced, although canopy base heights increased. The experiment accomplished the goal of minimally impacting the forest ecosystem but the effects of small-tree thinning plus burning were nearly indistinguishable from those of burning alone. All the treated units were left with modest gain in resistance to severe wildfires but in conditions still far removed from prefire-exclusion conditions.",
keywords = "Ecological restoration, Fire, Fuel reduction, Southwest",
author = "Fule, {Peter Z} and Covington, {Wallace W} and Stoddard, {Michael T.} and Don Bertolette",
year = "2006",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1111/j.1526-100X.2006.00144.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "14",
pages = "357--368",
journal = "Restoration Ecology",
issn = "1061-2971",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - "Minimal-Impact" restoration treatments have limited effects on forest structure and fuels at Grand Canyon, USA

AU - Fule, Peter Z

AU - Covington, Wallace W

AU - Stoddard, Michael T.

AU - Bertolette, Don

PY - 2006/9

Y1 - 2006/9

N2 - Restoration treatments were tested on the South Rim (ponderosa pine) and North Rim (mixed conifer) of Grand Canyon National Park, never-harvested forests where the historically frequent surface regime was interrupted in the late 19th century. Treatments were designed for "minimal impact"by limiting the size of trees to be thinned and minimizing mechanical equipment. Treatments included (1) thinning of small trees (diameter ≤ 12.7 cm) and prescribed fire; (2) thinning of small trees located close to large old trees and prescribed fire; (3) prescribed fire only; and (4) control. On the South Rim, density declined by 23-45% but basal area only by 9-14%. On the North Rim, density was reduced 32-68% and basal area declined 18-31%. Declines of 5-8% were observed in these same variables in the controls. Surface fuels were significantly reduced in all burned treatments (70-84% reduction in forest floor, 66-76% reduction in woody debris). However, canopy cover was nearly unchanged, and canopy fuel loads were not significantly reduced, although canopy base heights increased. The experiment accomplished the goal of minimally impacting the forest ecosystem but the effects of small-tree thinning plus burning were nearly indistinguishable from those of burning alone. All the treated units were left with modest gain in resistance to severe wildfires but in conditions still far removed from prefire-exclusion conditions.

AB - Restoration treatments were tested on the South Rim (ponderosa pine) and North Rim (mixed conifer) of Grand Canyon National Park, never-harvested forests where the historically frequent surface regime was interrupted in the late 19th century. Treatments were designed for "minimal impact"by limiting the size of trees to be thinned and minimizing mechanical equipment. Treatments included (1) thinning of small trees (diameter ≤ 12.7 cm) and prescribed fire; (2) thinning of small trees located close to large old trees and prescribed fire; (3) prescribed fire only; and (4) control. On the South Rim, density declined by 23-45% but basal area only by 9-14%. On the North Rim, density was reduced 32-68% and basal area declined 18-31%. Declines of 5-8% were observed in these same variables in the controls. Surface fuels were significantly reduced in all burned treatments (70-84% reduction in forest floor, 66-76% reduction in woody debris). However, canopy cover was nearly unchanged, and canopy fuel loads were not significantly reduced, although canopy base heights increased. The experiment accomplished the goal of minimally impacting the forest ecosystem but the effects of small-tree thinning plus burning were nearly indistinguishable from those of burning alone. All the treated units were left with modest gain in resistance to severe wildfires but in conditions still far removed from prefire-exclusion conditions.

KW - Ecological restoration

KW - Fire

KW - Fuel reduction

KW - Southwest

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33747357285&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33747357285&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1526-100X.2006.00144.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1526-100X.2006.00144.x

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 357

EP - 368

JO - Restoration Ecology

JF - Restoration Ecology

SN - 1061-2971

IS - 3

ER -