Mercurian impact craters

Implications for polar ground ice

Nadine G. Barlow, Ruth A. Allen, Faith Vilas

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

19 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Recent radar observations of Mercury have detected strong depolarized echoes from the north and south polar regions which have been interpreted by some as ice deposits in the floors of permanently shadowed impact craters. We have used the experience from Mars, where subsurface ice lowers the depth-to-diameter ratio (d/D) of impact craters, to test for subsurface ice deposits on Mercury. This analysis determines the d/D ratios for 170 impact craters in the Borealis (north polar), Tolstoj (equatorial), Kuiper (equatorial), and Bach (south polar) quadrangles of the planet. Possible effects from sun angle and terrain were eliminated. To test whether d/D differences could be detected at Mariner 10 resolutions (∼1 km/pixel), we perform a similar analysis using Mariner 9 images of Mars which have similar resolutions. We demonstrate that d/D differences due to terrain softening can be detected between craters in the martian polar regions and the equatorial regions at the Mariner 9 resolutions. Although our initial results indicate that the south polar Bach Quadrangle has a statistically lower d/D than the north polar (Borealis) or two equatorial (Tolstoj and Kuiper) quadrangles, further investigation reveals that this finding is most likely the result of the filtering which was applied to the images of the Bach quadrangle by JPL. Thus, no unequivocal evidence exists that the possible ice deposits in craters at Mercury's north and south poles are the exposed portions of more extensive subsurface ice caps. Combined with the temporal constraint imposed by the fact that the proposed ice deposits are found only in USGS Class 4 craters, this suggests a large, rapidly emplaced exogenic source of water to Mercury during the Mansurian period. We suggest that the source was multiple impacts from a fragmented comet or a comet shower.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)194-204
Number of pages11
JournalIcarus
Volume141
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 1999
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

craters
crater
ice
deposits
polar region
comets
polar regions
mars
comet
Mars
equatorial regions
radar tracking
ice cap
showers
softening
caps
planets
echoes
pixel
sun

Keywords

  • Cratering
  • Ices
  • Mars
  • Mercury
  • Surfaces, planets

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Space and Planetary Science
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics

Cite this

Mercurian impact craters : Implications for polar ground ice. / Barlow, Nadine G.; Allen, Ruth A.; Vilas, Faith.

In: Icarus, Vol. 141, No. 2, 10.1999, p. 194-204.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Barlow, Nadine G. ; Allen, Ruth A. ; Vilas, Faith. / Mercurian impact craters : Implications for polar ground ice. In: Icarus. 1999 ; Vol. 141, No. 2. pp. 194-204.
@article{f2b04c40ab914d3893e6f7947cf93950,
title = "Mercurian impact craters: Implications for polar ground ice",
abstract = "Recent radar observations of Mercury have detected strong depolarized echoes from the north and south polar regions which have been interpreted by some as ice deposits in the floors of permanently shadowed impact craters. We have used the experience from Mars, where subsurface ice lowers the depth-to-diameter ratio (d/D) of impact craters, to test for subsurface ice deposits on Mercury. This analysis determines the d/D ratios for 170 impact craters in the Borealis (north polar), Tolstoj (equatorial), Kuiper (equatorial), and Bach (south polar) quadrangles of the planet. Possible effects from sun angle and terrain were eliminated. To test whether d/D differences could be detected at Mariner 10 resolutions (∼1 km/pixel), we perform a similar analysis using Mariner 9 images of Mars which have similar resolutions. We demonstrate that d/D differences due to terrain softening can be detected between craters in the martian polar regions and the equatorial regions at the Mariner 9 resolutions. Although our initial results indicate that the south polar Bach Quadrangle has a statistically lower d/D than the north polar (Borealis) or two equatorial (Tolstoj and Kuiper) quadrangles, further investigation reveals that this finding is most likely the result of the filtering which was applied to the images of the Bach quadrangle by JPL. Thus, no unequivocal evidence exists that the possible ice deposits in craters at Mercury's north and south poles are the exposed portions of more extensive subsurface ice caps. Combined with the temporal constraint imposed by the fact that the proposed ice deposits are found only in USGS Class 4 craters, this suggests a large, rapidly emplaced exogenic source of water to Mercury during the Mansurian period. We suggest that the source was multiple impacts from a fragmented comet or a comet shower.",
keywords = "Cratering, Ices, Mars, Mercury, Surfaces, planets",
author = "Barlow, {Nadine G.} and Allen, {Ruth A.} and Faith Vilas",
year = "1999",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1006/icar.1999.6165",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "141",
pages = "194--204",
journal = "Icarus",
issn = "0019-1035",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Mercurian impact craters

T2 - Implications for polar ground ice

AU - Barlow, Nadine G.

AU - Allen, Ruth A.

AU - Vilas, Faith

PY - 1999/10

Y1 - 1999/10

N2 - Recent radar observations of Mercury have detected strong depolarized echoes from the north and south polar regions which have been interpreted by some as ice deposits in the floors of permanently shadowed impact craters. We have used the experience from Mars, where subsurface ice lowers the depth-to-diameter ratio (d/D) of impact craters, to test for subsurface ice deposits on Mercury. This analysis determines the d/D ratios for 170 impact craters in the Borealis (north polar), Tolstoj (equatorial), Kuiper (equatorial), and Bach (south polar) quadrangles of the planet. Possible effects from sun angle and terrain were eliminated. To test whether d/D differences could be detected at Mariner 10 resolutions (∼1 km/pixel), we perform a similar analysis using Mariner 9 images of Mars which have similar resolutions. We demonstrate that d/D differences due to terrain softening can be detected between craters in the martian polar regions and the equatorial regions at the Mariner 9 resolutions. Although our initial results indicate that the south polar Bach Quadrangle has a statistically lower d/D than the north polar (Borealis) or two equatorial (Tolstoj and Kuiper) quadrangles, further investigation reveals that this finding is most likely the result of the filtering which was applied to the images of the Bach quadrangle by JPL. Thus, no unequivocal evidence exists that the possible ice deposits in craters at Mercury's north and south poles are the exposed portions of more extensive subsurface ice caps. Combined with the temporal constraint imposed by the fact that the proposed ice deposits are found only in USGS Class 4 craters, this suggests a large, rapidly emplaced exogenic source of water to Mercury during the Mansurian period. We suggest that the source was multiple impacts from a fragmented comet or a comet shower.

AB - Recent radar observations of Mercury have detected strong depolarized echoes from the north and south polar regions which have been interpreted by some as ice deposits in the floors of permanently shadowed impact craters. We have used the experience from Mars, where subsurface ice lowers the depth-to-diameter ratio (d/D) of impact craters, to test for subsurface ice deposits on Mercury. This analysis determines the d/D ratios for 170 impact craters in the Borealis (north polar), Tolstoj (equatorial), Kuiper (equatorial), and Bach (south polar) quadrangles of the planet. Possible effects from sun angle and terrain were eliminated. To test whether d/D differences could be detected at Mariner 10 resolutions (∼1 km/pixel), we perform a similar analysis using Mariner 9 images of Mars which have similar resolutions. We demonstrate that d/D differences due to terrain softening can be detected between craters in the martian polar regions and the equatorial regions at the Mariner 9 resolutions. Although our initial results indicate that the south polar Bach Quadrangle has a statistically lower d/D than the north polar (Borealis) or two equatorial (Tolstoj and Kuiper) quadrangles, further investigation reveals that this finding is most likely the result of the filtering which was applied to the images of the Bach quadrangle by JPL. Thus, no unequivocal evidence exists that the possible ice deposits in craters at Mercury's north and south poles are the exposed portions of more extensive subsurface ice caps. Combined with the temporal constraint imposed by the fact that the proposed ice deposits are found only in USGS Class 4 craters, this suggests a large, rapidly emplaced exogenic source of water to Mercury during the Mansurian period. We suggest that the source was multiple impacts from a fragmented comet or a comet shower.

KW - Cratering

KW - Ices

KW - Mars

KW - Mercury

KW - Surfaces, planets

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0033209480&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0033209480&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1006/icar.1999.6165

DO - 10.1006/icar.1999.6165

M3 - Article

VL - 141

SP - 194

EP - 204

JO - Icarus

JF - Icarus

SN - 0019-1035

IS - 2

ER -