Isotopic age of the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, Arizona: An example of dating a continental sandstone

Nancy R Riggs, S. R. Ash, A. P. Barth, G. E. Gehrels, J. L. Wooden

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

42 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Zircons from the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, in Petrified Forest National Park, yield ages that range from Late Triassic to Late Archean. Grains were analyzed by multigrain TIMS (thermal-ionization mass spectrometry), single-crystal TIMS, and SHRIMP (sensitive, high-resolution ion-microprobe). Multiple-grain analysis yielded a discordia trajectory with a lower intercept of 207 ± 2 Ma, which because of the nature of multiple-grain sampling of a detrital bed, is not considered conclusive. Analysis of 29 detrital-zircon grains by TIMS yielded U-PB ages of 2706 ± 6 Ma to 206 ± 6 Ma. Eleven of these ages lie between 211 and 216 ± 6.8 Ma. Our statistical analysis of these grains indicates that the mean of the ages, 213 ± 1.7 Ma, reflects more analytical error than geologic variability in sources of the grains. Grains with ages of ca. 1400 Ma were derived from the widespread plutons of that age exposed throughout the southwestern Cordillera and central United States. Twelve grains analyzed by SHRIMP provide 206Pb*/238U ages from 214 ± 2 Ma to 200 ± 4 Ma. We use these data to infer that cores of inherited material were present in many zircons and that single-crystal analysis provides an accurate estimation of the age of the bed. We further propose that, even if some degree of reworking has occurred, the very strong concentration of ages at ca. 213 Ma provides a maximum age for the Black Forest Bed of 213 ± 1.7 Ma. The actual age of the bed may be closer to 209 Ma. Dating continental successions is very difficult when distinct ash beds are not clearly identified, as is the case in the Chinle Formation. Detrital zircons in the Black Forest Bed, however, are dominated by an acicular morphology with preserved delicate terminations. The shape of these crystals and their inferred environment of deposition in slow-water settings suggest that the crystals were not far removed from their site of deposition in space and likely not far in time. Plinian ash clouds derived from explosive eruptions along the early Mesozoic Cordilleran margin provided the crystals to the Chinle basin, where local conditions insured their preservation. In the case of the Black Forest Bed, the products of one major eruption may dominate the volcanic contribution to the unit. Volcanic detritus in the Chinle Formation was derived from multiple, distinct sources. Coarse pebble- to cobble-size material may have originated in eastern California and/or western Arizona, where Triassic plutons are exposed. Fine-grained detritus, in contrast, was carried in ash clouds that derived from caldera eruptions in east-central California or western Nevada.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1315-1323
Number of pages9
JournalBulletin of the Geological Society of America
Volume115
Issue number11
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 2003

Fingerprint

sandstone
crystal
zircon
ionization
ash
volcanic eruption
mass spectrometry
ion microprobe
detritus
pluton
dating
Triassic
pebble
reworking
caldera
cordillera
explosive
Archean
statistical analysis
national park

Keywords

  • Chinle Formation
  • Isotopic dating
  • SHRIMP
  • Single-crystal TIMS
  • Triassic

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Earth and Planetary Sciences (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Isotopic age of the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, Arizona : An example of dating a continental sandstone. / Riggs, Nancy R; Ash, S. R.; Barth, A. P.; Gehrels, G. E.; Wooden, J. L.

In: Bulletin of the Geological Society of America, Vol. 115, No. 11, 11.2003, p. 1315-1323.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9388eef635ab4c958d6458b1fb63f816,
title = "Isotopic age of the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, Arizona: An example of dating a continental sandstone",
abstract = "Zircons from the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, in Petrified Forest National Park, yield ages that range from Late Triassic to Late Archean. Grains were analyzed by multigrain TIMS (thermal-ionization mass spectrometry), single-crystal TIMS, and SHRIMP (sensitive, high-resolution ion-microprobe). Multiple-grain analysis yielded a discordia trajectory with a lower intercept of 207 ± 2 Ma, which because of the nature of multiple-grain sampling of a detrital bed, is not considered conclusive. Analysis of 29 detrital-zircon grains by TIMS yielded U-PB ages of 2706 ± 6 Ma to 206 ± 6 Ma. Eleven of these ages lie between 211 and 216 ± 6.8 Ma. Our statistical analysis of these grains indicates that the mean of the ages, 213 ± 1.7 Ma, reflects more analytical error than geologic variability in sources of the grains. Grains with ages of ca. 1400 Ma were derived from the widespread plutons of that age exposed throughout the southwestern Cordillera and central United States. Twelve grains analyzed by SHRIMP provide 206Pb*/238U ages from 214 ± 2 Ma to 200 ± 4 Ma. We use these data to infer that cores of inherited material were present in many zircons and that single-crystal analysis provides an accurate estimation of the age of the bed. We further propose that, even if some degree of reworking has occurred, the very strong concentration of ages at ca. 213 Ma provides a maximum age for the Black Forest Bed of 213 ± 1.7 Ma. The actual age of the bed may be closer to 209 Ma. Dating continental successions is very difficult when distinct ash beds are not clearly identified, as is the case in the Chinle Formation. Detrital zircons in the Black Forest Bed, however, are dominated by an acicular morphology with preserved delicate terminations. The shape of these crystals and their inferred environment of deposition in slow-water settings suggest that the crystals were not far removed from their site of deposition in space and likely not far in time. Plinian ash clouds derived from explosive eruptions along the early Mesozoic Cordilleran margin provided the crystals to the Chinle basin, where local conditions insured their preservation. In the case of the Black Forest Bed, the products of one major eruption may dominate the volcanic contribution to the unit. Volcanic detritus in the Chinle Formation was derived from multiple, distinct sources. Coarse pebble- to cobble-size material may have originated in eastern California and/or western Arizona, where Triassic plutons are exposed. Fine-grained detritus, in contrast, was carried in ash clouds that derived from caldera eruptions in east-central California or western Nevada.",
keywords = "Chinle Formation, Isotopic dating, SHRIMP, Single-crystal TIMS, Triassic",
author = "Riggs, {Nancy R} and Ash, {S. R.} and Barth, {A. P.} and Gehrels, {G. E.} and Wooden, {J. L.}",
year = "2003",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1130/B25254.1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "115",
pages = "1315--1323",
journal = "Geological Society of America Bulletin",
issn = "0016-7606",
publisher = "Geological Society of America",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Isotopic age of the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, Arizona

T2 - An example of dating a continental sandstone

AU - Riggs, Nancy R

AU - Ash, S. R.

AU - Barth, A. P.

AU - Gehrels, G. E.

AU - Wooden, J. L.

PY - 2003/11

Y1 - 2003/11

N2 - Zircons from the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, in Petrified Forest National Park, yield ages that range from Late Triassic to Late Archean. Grains were analyzed by multigrain TIMS (thermal-ionization mass spectrometry), single-crystal TIMS, and SHRIMP (sensitive, high-resolution ion-microprobe). Multiple-grain analysis yielded a discordia trajectory with a lower intercept of 207 ± 2 Ma, which because of the nature of multiple-grain sampling of a detrital bed, is not considered conclusive. Analysis of 29 detrital-zircon grains by TIMS yielded U-PB ages of 2706 ± 6 Ma to 206 ± 6 Ma. Eleven of these ages lie between 211 and 216 ± 6.8 Ma. Our statistical analysis of these grains indicates that the mean of the ages, 213 ± 1.7 Ma, reflects more analytical error than geologic variability in sources of the grains. Grains with ages of ca. 1400 Ma were derived from the widespread plutons of that age exposed throughout the southwestern Cordillera and central United States. Twelve grains analyzed by SHRIMP provide 206Pb*/238U ages from 214 ± 2 Ma to 200 ± 4 Ma. We use these data to infer that cores of inherited material were present in many zircons and that single-crystal analysis provides an accurate estimation of the age of the bed. We further propose that, even if some degree of reworking has occurred, the very strong concentration of ages at ca. 213 Ma provides a maximum age for the Black Forest Bed of 213 ± 1.7 Ma. The actual age of the bed may be closer to 209 Ma. Dating continental successions is very difficult when distinct ash beds are not clearly identified, as is the case in the Chinle Formation. Detrital zircons in the Black Forest Bed, however, are dominated by an acicular morphology with preserved delicate terminations. The shape of these crystals and their inferred environment of deposition in slow-water settings suggest that the crystals were not far removed from their site of deposition in space and likely not far in time. Plinian ash clouds derived from explosive eruptions along the early Mesozoic Cordilleran margin provided the crystals to the Chinle basin, where local conditions insured their preservation. In the case of the Black Forest Bed, the products of one major eruption may dominate the volcanic contribution to the unit. Volcanic detritus in the Chinle Formation was derived from multiple, distinct sources. Coarse pebble- to cobble-size material may have originated in eastern California and/or western Arizona, where Triassic plutons are exposed. Fine-grained detritus, in contrast, was carried in ash clouds that derived from caldera eruptions in east-central California or western Nevada.

AB - Zircons from the Black Forest Bed, Petrified Forest Member, Chinle Formation, in Petrified Forest National Park, yield ages that range from Late Triassic to Late Archean. Grains were analyzed by multigrain TIMS (thermal-ionization mass spectrometry), single-crystal TIMS, and SHRIMP (sensitive, high-resolution ion-microprobe). Multiple-grain analysis yielded a discordia trajectory with a lower intercept of 207 ± 2 Ma, which because of the nature of multiple-grain sampling of a detrital bed, is not considered conclusive. Analysis of 29 detrital-zircon grains by TIMS yielded U-PB ages of 2706 ± 6 Ma to 206 ± 6 Ma. Eleven of these ages lie between 211 and 216 ± 6.8 Ma. Our statistical analysis of these grains indicates that the mean of the ages, 213 ± 1.7 Ma, reflects more analytical error than geologic variability in sources of the grains. Grains with ages of ca. 1400 Ma were derived from the widespread plutons of that age exposed throughout the southwestern Cordillera and central United States. Twelve grains analyzed by SHRIMP provide 206Pb*/238U ages from 214 ± 2 Ma to 200 ± 4 Ma. We use these data to infer that cores of inherited material were present in many zircons and that single-crystal analysis provides an accurate estimation of the age of the bed. We further propose that, even if some degree of reworking has occurred, the very strong concentration of ages at ca. 213 Ma provides a maximum age for the Black Forest Bed of 213 ± 1.7 Ma. The actual age of the bed may be closer to 209 Ma. Dating continental successions is very difficult when distinct ash beds are not clearly identified, as is the case in the Chinle Formation. Detrital zircons in the Black Forest Bed, however, are dominated by an acicular morphology with preserved delicate terminations. The shape of these crystals and their inferred environment of deposition in slow-water settings suggest that the crystals were not far removed from their site of deposition in space and likely not far in time. Plinian ash clouds derived from explosive eruptions along the early Mesozoic Cordilleran margin provided the crystals to the Chinle basin, where local conditions insured their preservation. In the case of the Black Forest Bed, the products of one major eruption may dominate the volcanic contribution to the unit. Volcanic detritus in the Chinle Formation was derived from multiple, distinct sources. Coarse pebble- to cobble-size material may have originated in eastern California and/or western Arizona, where Triassic plutons are exposed. Fine-grained detritus, in contrast, was carried in ash clouds that derived from caldera eruptions in east-central California or western Nevada.

KW - Chinle Formation

KW - Isotopic dating

KW - SHRIMP

KW - Single-crystal TIMS

KW - Triassic

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0346749370&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0346749370&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1130/B25254.1

DO - 10.1130/B25254.1

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:0346749370

VL - 115

SP - 1315

EP - 1323

JO - Geological Society of America Bulletin

JF - Geological Society of America Bulletin

SN - 0016-7606

IS - 11

ER -