From tusko to titin

The role for comparative physiology in an era of molecular discovery

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

As we approach the centenary of the term “comparative physiology,” we reexamine its role in modern biology. Finding inspiration in Krogh’s classic 1929 paper, we first look back to some timeless contributions to the field. The obvious and fascinating variation among animals is much more evident than is their shared physiological unity, which transcends both body size and specific adaptations. The “unity in diversity” reveals general patterns and principles of physiology that are invisible when examining only one species. Next, we examine selected contemporary contributions to comparative physiology, which provides the context in which reductionist experiments are best interpreted. We discuss the sometimes surprising insights provided by two comparative “athletes” (pronghorn and rattlesnakes), which demonstrate 1) animals are not isolated molecular mechanisms but highly integrated physiological machines, a single “rate-limiting” step may be exceptional; and 2) extremes in nature are rarely the result of novel mechanisms, but rather employ existing solutions in novel ways. Furthermore, rattlesnake tailshaker muscle effectively abolished the conventional view of incompatibility of simultaneous sustained anaerobic glycolysis and oxidative ATP production. We end this review by looking forward, much as Krogh did, to suggest that a comparative approach may best lend insights in unraveling how skeletal muscle stores and recovers mechanical energy when operating cyclically. We discuss and speculate on the role of the largest known protein, titin (the third muscle filament), as a dynamic spring capable of storing and recovering elastic recoil potential energy in skeletal muscle.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)R983-R989
JournalAmerican Journal of Physiology - Regulatory Integrative and Comparative Physiology
Volume308
Issue number12
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 12 2015

Fingerprint

Comparative Physiology
Connectin
Crotalus
Skeletal Muscle
Muscles
Body Size
Glycolysis
Athletes
Adenosine Triphosphate
Proteins

Keywords

  • Allometry
  • Connectin
  • Muscle activation
  • Muscle contraction
  • Muscular dystrophy with myositis (Mdm)
  • Winding filament hypothesis

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Physiology
  • Physiology (medical)

Cite this

@article{097c262c7555456a83ff0c830eeeedaa,
title = "From tusko to titin: The role for comparative physiology in an era of molecular discovery",
abstract = "As we approach the centenary of the term “comparative physiology,” we reexamine its role in modern biology. Finding inspiration in Krogh’s classic 1929 paper, we first look back to some timeless contributions to the field. The obvious and fascinating variation among animals is much more evident than is their shared physiological unity, which transcends both body size and specific adaptations. The “unity in diversity” reveals general patterns and principles of physiology that are invisible when examining only one species. Next, we examine selected contemporary contributions to comparative physiology, which provides the context in which reductionist experiments are best interpreted. We discuss the sometimes surprising insights provided by two comparative “athletes” (pronghorn and rattlesnakes), which demonstrate 1) animals are not isolated molecular mechanisms but highly integrated physiological machines, a single “rate-limiting” step may be exceptional; and 2) extremes in nature are rarely the result of novel mechanisms, but rather employ existing solutions in novel ways. Furthermore, rattlesnake tailshaker muscle effectively abolished the conventional view of incompatibility of simultaneous sustained anaerobic glycolysis and oxidative ATP production. We end this review by looking forward, much as Krogh did, to suggest that a comparative approach may best lend insights in unraveling how skeletal muscle stores and recovers mechanical energy when operating cyclically. We discuss and speculate on the role of the largest known protein, titin (the third muscle filament), as a dynamic spring capable of storing and recovering elastic recoil potential energy in skeletal muscle.",
keywords = "Allometry, Connectin, Muscle activation, Muscle contraction, Muscular dystrophy with myositis (Mdm), Winding filament hypothesis",
author = "Lindstedt, {Stan L} and Nishikawa, {Kiisa C}",
year = "2015",
month = "6",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1152/ajpregu.00405.2014",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "308",
pages = "R983--R989",
journal = "American Journal of Physiology",
issn = "0363-6119",
publisher = "American Physiological Society",
number = "12",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - From tusko to titin

T2 - The role for comparative physiology in an era of molecular discovery

AU - Lindstedt, Stan L

AU - Nishikawa, Kiisa C

PY - 2015/6/12

Y1 - 2015/6/12

N2 - As we approach the centenary of the term “comparative physiology,” we reexamine its role in modern biology. Finding inspiration in Krogh’s classic 1929 paper, we first look back to some timeless contributions to the field. The obvious and fascinating variation among animals is much more evident than is their shared physiological unity, which transcends both body size and specific adaptations. The “unity in diversity” reveals general patterns and principles of physiology that are invisible when examining only one species. Next, we examine selected contemporary contributions to comparative physiology, which provides the context in which reductionist experiments are best interpreted. We discuss the sometimes surprising insights provided by two comparative “athletes” (pronghorn and rattlesnakes), which demonstrate 1) animals are not isolated molecular mechanisms but highly integrated physiological machines, a single “rate-limiting” step may be exceptional; and 2) extremes in nature are rarely the result of novel mechanisms, but rather employ existing solutions in novel ways. Furthermore, rattlesnake tailshaker muscle effectively abolished the conventional view of incompatibility of simultaneous sustained anaerobic glycolysis and oxidative ATP production. We end this review by looking forward, much as Krogh did, to suggest that a comparative approach may best lend insights in unraveling how skeletal muscle stores and recovers mechanical energy when operating cyclically. We discuss and speculate on the role of the largest known protein, titin (the third muscle filament), as a dynamic spring capable of storing and recovering elastic recoil potential energy in skeletal muscle.

AB - As we approach the centenary of the term “comparative physiology,” we reexamine its role in modern biology. Finding inspiration in Krogh’s classic 1929 paper, we first look back to some timeless contributions to the field. The obvious and fascinating variation among animals is much more evident than is their shared physiological unity, which transcends both body size and specific adaptations. The “unity in diversity” reveals general patterns and principles of physiology that are invisible when examining only one species. Next, we examine selected contemporary contributions to comparative physiology, which provides the context in which reductionist experiments are best interpreted. We discuss the sometimes surprising insights provided by two comparative “athletes” (pronghorn and rattlesnakes), which demonstrate 1) animals are not isolated molecular mechanisms but highly integrated physiological machines, a single “rate-limiting” step may be exceptional; and 2) extremes in nature are rarely the result of novel mechanisms, but rather employ existing solutions in novel ways. Furthermore, rattlesnake tailshaker muscle effectively abolished the conventional view of incompatibility of simultaneous sustained anaerobic glycolysis and oxidative ATP production. We end this review by looking forward, much as Krogh did, to suggest that a comparative approach may best lend insights in unraveling how skeletal muscle stores and recovers mechanical energy when operating cyclically. We discuss and speculate on the role of the largest known protein, titin (the third muscle filament), as a dynamic spring capable of storing and recovering elastic recoil potential energy in skeletal muscle.

KW - Allometry

KW - Connectin

KW - Muscle activation

KW - Muscle contraction

KW - Muscular dystrophy with myositis (Mdm)

KW - Winding filament hypothesis

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84931067562&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84931067562&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1152/ajpregu.00405.2014

DO - 10.1152/ajpregu.00405.2014

M3 - Article

VL - 308

SP - R983-R989

JO - American Journal of Physiology

JF - American Journal of Physiology

SN - 0363-6119

IS - 12

ER -