Fast-growing juvenile pinyons suffer greater herbivory when mature

Jonathan Ruel, Thomas G Whitham

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

28 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We examined the hypothesis that tree-ring analyses of juvenile growth traits could be used to predict herbivory during mature years. At Sunset Crater National Monument, Arizona, USA, some pinyon pines (Pinus edulis) are highly susceptible to the stem-boring moth, Dioryctria albovittella, and suffer chronic attack, while other adjacent trees are resistant and have remained relatively moth-free for years. Five major patterns emerged: (1) Susceptible trees suffer from 11 times more shoots killed per tree and produce <0.05 times as many cones as resistant trees. (2) This herbivore is largely restricted to reproductively mature trees that, at this site, are generally older than 46 yr. (3) Analysis of tree-ring data from resistant and susceptible trees shows that trees that eventually became susceptible grew more vigorously during their attack-free juvenile years than resistant trees (growth rings were 29% wider). However, when they matured and suffered chronic herbivory, susceptible trees produced growth rings 13% smaller than resistant trees. (4) Although previous studies showed that resistance was associated with higher oleoresin flow, we did not observe this pattern. Instead, we found that resistance was best correlated with slower juvenile growth rates. Current-year shoots of susceptible mature trees averaged 50% larger than those on resistant mature trees. (5) Tree-ring analyses supported the hypothesis of a trade-off between growth and resistance. This study shows that dendrochronology can be used as a tool to predict future herbivory and demonstrates that the fastest growing juvenile trees suffer the poorest performance decades later when they become moth-susceptible mature trees. Furthermore, it illustrates that traits associated with plant development can greatly affect herbivore distributions, and that herbivore selection pressures on juvenile trees can be very different than on mature trees.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)2691-2699
Number of pages9
JournalEcology
Volume83
Issue number10
StatePublished - Oct 1 2002

Fingerprint

herbivory
herbivores
growth rings
tree ring
moths
moth
dendrochronology
herbivore
Dioryctria
Pinus edulis
shoot
seed cones
oleoresins
shoots
growth traits
monument
boring
plant development
trade-off
crater

Keywords

  • Dendrochronology
  • Dioryctria albovittella
  • Herbivory
  • Pine
  • Pinus edulis
  • Pinyon
  • Plant vigor
  • Plant-herbivore interactions
  • Sunset Crater National Monument, Arizona, USA
  • Tree rings

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Fast-growing juvenile pinyons suffer greater herbivory when mature. / Ruel, Jonathan; Whitham, Thomas G.

In: Ecology, Vol. 83, No. 10, 01.10.2002, p. 2691-2699.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ruel, Jonathan ; Whitham, Thomas G. / Fast-growing juvenile pinyons suffer greater herbivory when mature. In: Ecology. 2002 ; Vol. 83, No. 10. pp. 2691-2699.
@article{4c61043841d44e4f87bb29ad693f1370,
title = "Fast-growing juvenile pinyons suffer greater herbivory when mature",
abstract = "We examined the hypothesis that tree-ring analyses of juvenile growth traits could be used to predict herbivory during mature years. At Sunset Crater National Monument, Arizona, USA, some pinyon pines (Pinus edulis) are highly susceptible to the stem-boring moth, Dioryctria albovittella, and suffer chronic attack, while other adjacent trees are resistant and have remained relatively moth-free for years. Five major patterns emerged: (1) Susceptible trees suffer from 11 times more shoots killed per tree and produce <0.05 times as many cones as resistant trees. (2) This herbivore is largely restricted to reproductively mature trees that, at this site, are generally older than 46 yr. (3) Analysis of tree-ring data from resistant and susceptible trees shows that trees that eventually became susceptible grew more vigorously during their attack-free juvenile years than resistant trees (growth rings were 29{\%} wider). However, when they matured and suffered chronic herbivory, susceptible trees produced growth rings 13{\%} smaller than resistant trees. (4) Although previous studies showed that resistance was associated with higher oleoresin flow, we did not observe this pattern. Instead, we found that resistance was best correlated with slower juvenile growth rates. Current-year shoots of susceptible mature trees averaged 50{\%} larger than those on resistant mature trees. (5) Tree-ring analyses supported the hypothesis of a trade-off between growth and resistance. This study shows that dendrochronology can be used as a tool to predict future herbivory and demonstrates that the fastest growing juvenile trees suffer the poorest performance decades later when they become moth-susceptible mature trees. Furthermore, it illustrates that traits associated with plant development can greatly affect herbivore distributions, and that herbivore selection pressures on juvenile trees can be very different than on mature trees.",
keywords = "Dendrochronology, Dioryctria albovittella, Herbivory, Pine, Pinus edulis, Pinyon, Plant vigor, Plant-herbivore interactions, Sunset Crater National Monument, Arizona, USA, Tree rings",
author = "Jonathan Ruel and Whitham, {Thomas G}",
year = "2002",
month = "10",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "83",
pages = "2691--2699",
journal = "Ecology",
issn = "0012-9658",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Fast-growing juvenile pinyons suffer greater herbivory when mature

AU - Ruel, Jonathan

AU - Whitham, Thomas G

PY - 2002/10/1

Y1 - 2002/10/1

N2 - We examined the hypothesis that tree-ring analyses of juvenile growth traits could be used to predict herbivory during mature years. At Sunset Crater National Monument, Arizona, USA, some pinyon pines (Pinus edulis) are highly susceptible to the stem-boring moth, Dioryctria albovittella, and suffer chronic attack, while other adjacent trees are resistant and have remained relatively moth-free for years. Five major patterns emerged: (1) Susceptible trees suffer from 11 times more shoots killed per tree and produce <0.05 times as many cones as resistant trees. (2) This herbivore is largely restricted to reproductively mature trees that, at this site, are generally older than 46 yr. (3) Analysis of tree-ring data from resistant and susceptible trees shows that trees that eventually became susceptible grew more vigorously during their attack-free juvenile years than resistant trees (growth rings were 29% wider). However, when they matured and suffered chronic herbivory, susceptible trees produced growth rings 13% smaller than resistant trees. (4) Although previous studies showed that resistance was associated with higher oleoresin flow, we did not observe this pattern. Instead, we found that resistance was best correlated with slower juvenile growth rates. Current-year shoots of susceptible mature trees averaged 50% larger than those on resistant mature trees. (5) Tree-ring analyses supported the hypothesis of a trade-off between growth and resistance. This study shows that dendrochronology can be used as a tool to predict future herbivory and demonstrates that the fastest growing juvenile trees suffer the poorest performance decades later when they become moth-susceptible mature trees. Furthermore, it illustrates that traits associated with plant development can greatly affect herbivore distributions, and that herbivore selection pressures on juvenile trees can be very different than on mature trees.

AB - We examined the hypothesis that tree-ring analyses of juvenile growth traits could be used to predict herbivory during mature years. At Sunset Crater National Monument, Arizona, USA, some pinyon pines (Pinus edulis) are highly susceptible to the stem-boring moth, Dioryctria albovittella, and suffer chronic attack, while other adjacent trees are resistant and have remained relatively moth-free for years. Five major patterns emerged: (1) Susceptible trees suffer from 11 times more shoots killed per tree and produce <0.05 times as many cones as resistant trees. (2) This herbivore is largely restricted to reproductively mature trees that, at this site, are generally older than 46 yr. (3) Analysis of tree-ring data from resistant and susceptible trees shows that trees that eventually became susceptible grew more vigorously during their attack-free juvenile years than resistant trees (growth rings were 29% wider). However, when they matured and suffered chronic herbivory, susceptible trees produced growth rings 13% smaller than resistant trees. (4) Although previous studies showed that resistance was associated with higher oleoresin flow, we did not observe this pattern. Instead, we found that resistance was best correlated with slower juvenile growth rates. Current-year shoots of susceptible mature trees averaged 50% larger than those on resistant mature trees. (5) Tree-ring analyses supported the hypothesis of a trade-off between growth and resistance. This study shows that dendrochronology can be used as a tool to predict future herbivory and demonstrates that the fastest growing juvenile trees suffer the poorest performance decades later when they become moth-susceptible mature trees. Furthermore, it illustrates that traits associated with plant development can greatly affect herbivore distributions, and that herbivore selection pressures on juvenile trees can be very different than on mature trees.

KW - Dendrochronology

KW - Dioryctria albovittella

KW - Herbivory

KW - Pine

KW - Pinus edulis

KW - Pinyon

KW - Plant vigor

KW - Plant-herbivore interactions

KW - Sunset Crater National Monument, Arizona, USA

KW - Tree rings

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0038138035&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0038138035&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 83

SP - 2691

EP - 2699

JO - Ecology

JF - Ecology

SN - 0012-9658

IS - 10

ER -