Evolution on a desert island

Body size divergence between the reptiles of Nevada's Anaho Island and the mainland around Pyramid Lake

J. E. Keehn, Nathan C Nieto, C. R. Tracy, C. M. Gienger, C. R. Feldman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Patterns of body size evolution on islands provide compelling cases of rapid and dramatic phenotypic evolution in terrestrial vertebrates, yet debate remains over the relative roles of predation and resource availability in driving such evolution. We compared the morphology of five reptile species (four lizards, one snake) from Anaho Island, a desert island in Pyramid Lake, Nevada, and the nearby mainland, using museum and live-caught animals. We also examined head-shape allometries to make inferences about dietary shifts and recorded tail-regeneration frequencies (in lizards) to examine predation intensity. Compared with mainland samples, two phyrnosomatid lizard species are larger on Anaho (Callisaurus draconoides and Sceloporus occidentalis), whereas the largest (S.uniformis) is not different on the island. Conversely, the teiid lizard Aspidoscelis tigris is smaller in body and head size on the island, and the pitviper Crotalus oreganus is especially diminutive on the island, with males and females 25 and 15% smaller, respectively. Our results appear consistent with the hypothesis that body size is related to resource availability. The change in body size of the two smaller phrynosomatids may be due to interference competition. The reduction in body and head size in A.tigris suggests a dietary shift, and the dramatic difference in C.oreganus is likely due to a switch in diet from mammals to lizards. Future work is needed to determine whether body size differences reflect genetic evolution or environmental differences in growth rates or resource use. Regardless, Anaho Island, although remarkably young (early Holocene), appears to harbour a unique community of reptiles with distinct morphologies and possibly divergent life histories.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)269-278
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Zoology
Volume291
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2013

Fingerprint

reptile
reptiles
deserts
body size
desert
divergence
lizard
lakes
lizards
lake
dietary shift
resource availability
Callisaurus draconoides
Sceloporus occidentalis
predation
Crotalus
interference competition
allometry
snake
crossover interference

Keywords

  • Aspidoscelis
  • Callisaurus
  • Competition
  • Crotalus
  • Dwarfism
  • Gigantism
  • Phrynosomatidae
  • Resource availability
  • Sceloporus
  • Teiidae
  • Viperidae

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Animal Science and Zoology
  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Evolution on a desert island : Body size divergence between the reptiles of Nevada's Anaho Island and the mainland around Pyramid Lake. / Keehn, J. E.; Nieto, Nathan C; Tracy, C. R.; Gienger, C. M.; Feldman, C. R.

In: Journal of Zoology, Vol. 291, No. 4, 12.2013, p. 269-278.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{355de0c5fb2744c3928326720acb7bd1,
title = "Evolution on a desert island: Body size divergence between the reptiles of Nevada's Anaho Island and the mainland around Pyramid Lake",
abstract = "Patterns of body size evolution on islands provide compelling cases of rapid and dramatic phenotypic evolution in terrestrial vertebrates, yet debate remains over the relative roles of predation and resource availability in driving such evolution. We compared the morphology of five reptile species (four lizards, one snake) from Anaho Island, a desert island in Pyramid Lake, Nevada, and the nearby mainland, using museum and live-caught animals. We also examined head-shape allometries to make inferences about dietary shifts and recorded tail-regeneration frequencies (in lizards) to examine predation intensity. Compared with mainland samples, two phyrnosomatid lizard species are larger on Anaho (Callisaurus draconoides and Sceloporus occidentalis), whereas the largest (S.uniformis) is not different on the island. Conversely, the teiid lizard Aspidoscelis tigris is smaller in body and head size on the island, and the pitviper Crotalus oreganus is especially diminutive on the island, with males and females 25 and 15{\%} smaller, respectively. Our results appear consistent with the hypothesis that body size is related to resource availability. The change in body size of the two smaller phrynosomatids may be due to interference competition. The reduction in body and head size in A.tigris suggests a dietary shift, and the dramatic difference in C.oreganus is likely due to a switch in diet from mammals to lizards. Future work is needed to determine whether body size differences reflect genetic evolution or environmental differences in growth rates or resource use. Regardless, Anaho Island, although remarkably young (early Holocene), appears to harbour a unique community of reptiles with distinct morphologies and possibly divergent life histories.",
keywords = "Aspidoscelis, Callisaurus, Competition, Crotalus, Dwarfism, Gigantism, Phrynosomatidae, Resource availability, Sceloporus, Teiidae, Viperidae",
author = "Keehn, {J. E.} and Nieto, {Nathan C} and Tracy, {C. R.} and Gienger, {C. M.} and Feldman, {C. R.}",
year = "2013",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1111/jzo.12066",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "291",
pages = "269--278",
journal = "Journal of Zoology",
issn = "0952-8369",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evolution on a desert island

T2 - Body size divergence between the reptiles of Nevada's Anaho Island and the mainland around Pyramid Lake

AU - Keehn, J. E.

AU - Nieto, Nathan C

AU - Tracy, C. R.

AU - Gienger, C. M.

AU - Feldman, C. R.

PY - 2013/12

Y1 - 2013/12

N2 - Patterns of body size evolution on islands provide compelling cases of rapid and dramatic phenotypic evolution in terrestrial vertebrates, yet debate remains over the relative roles of predation and resource availability in driving such evolution. We compared the morphology of five reptile species (four lizards, one snake) from Anaho Island, a desert island in Pyramid Lake, Nevada, and the nearby mainland, using museum and live-caught animals. We also examined head-shape allometries to make inferences about dietary shifts and recorded tail-regeneration frequencies (in lizards) to examine predation intensity. Compared with mainland samples, two phyrnosomatid lizard species are larger on Anaho (Callisaurus draconoides and Sceloporus occidentalis), whereas the largest (S.uniformis) is not different on the island. Conversely, the teiid lizard Aspidoscelis tigris is smaller in body and head size on the island, and the pitviper Crotalus oreganus is especially diminutive on the island, with males and females 25 and 15% smaller, respectively. Our results appear consistent with the hypothesis that body size is related to resource availability. The change in body size of the two smaller phrynosomatids may be due to interference competition. The reduction in body and head size in A.tigris suggests a dietary shift, and the dramatic difference in C.oreganus is likely due to a switch in diet from mammals to lizards. Future work is needed to determine whether body size differences reflect genetic evolution or environmental differences in growth rates or resource use. Regardless, Anaho Island, although remarkably young (early Holocene), appears to harbour a unique community of reptiles with distinct morphologies and possibly divergent life histories.

AB - Patterns of body size evolution on islands provide compelling cases of rapid and dramatic phenotypic evolution in terrestrial vertebrates, yet debate remains over the relative roles of predation and resource availability in driving such evolution. We compared the morphology of five reptile species (four lizards, one snake) from Anaho Island, a desert island in Pyramid Lake, Nevada, and the nearby mainland, using museum and live-caught animals. We also examined head-shape allometries to make inferences about dietary shifts and recorded tail-regeneration frequencies (in lizards) to examine predation intensity. Compared with mainland samples, two phyrnosomatid lizard species are larger on Anaho (Callisaurus draconoides and Sceloporus occidentalis), whereas the largest (S.uniformis) is not different on the island. Conversely, the teiid lizard Aspidoscelis tigris is smaller in body and head size on the island, and the pitviper Crotalus oreganus is especially diminutive on the island, with males and females 25 and 15% smaller, respectively. Our results appear consistent with the hypothesis that body size is related to resource availability. The change in body size of the two smaller phrynosomatids may be due to interference competition. The reduction in body and head size in A.tigris suggests a dietary shift, and the dramatic difference in C.oreganus is likely due to a switch in diet from mammals to lizards. Future work is needed to determine whether body size differences reflect genetic evolution or environmental differences in growth rates or resource use. Regardless, Anaho Island, although remarkably young (early Holocene), appears to harbour a unique community of reptiles with distinct morphologies and possibly divergent life histories.

KW - Aspidoscelis

KW - Callisaurus

KW - Competition

KW - Crotalus

KW - Dwarfism

KW - Gigantism

KW - Phrynosomatidae

KW - Resource availability

KW - Sceloporus

KW - Teiidae

KW - Viperidae

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84888433207&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84888433207&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/jzo.12066

DO - 10.1111/jzo.12066

M3 - Article

VL - 291

SP - 269

EP - 278

JO - Journal of Zoology

JF - Journal of Zoology

SN - 0952-8369

IS - 4

ER -