Discourse, Power, and the Diagnosis of Weakness

Encountering Practitioners in Bangladesh

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

16 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The author's experiences as a "patient" of nonbiomedical practitioners, and an examination of Bangladeshis' encounters with practitioners (dāktārs [biomedical doctors], herbalists, exorcists, and diviners), reveal the interactive means by which the diagnosis of durbalatā (weakness) is constructed. In the cases presented, facing power in the person of the practitioner means losing face. I argue that discursive phenomena above and below the lexical level are responsible. The phenomena described - (1) interruption or dismissal of the patient's words by practitioners and others present during the clinical encounter, (2) divinatory routines that assign the durbalatā label to women, and (3) one patient's use of "reaky" voice quality in a strictly "popular sector" (domestic) encounter - are nonreferential but socially significant semiotic processes that operate, for the most part, beneath the level of discursive awareness. These encounters and their outcomes have more to do with social reproduction than with any unambiguously effective therapeutic outcome.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)352-374
Number of pages23
JournalMedical Anthropology Quarterly
Volume11
Issue number3
StatePublished - 1997

Fingerprint

Bangladesh
dismissal
semiotics
examination
human being
discourse
present
Voice Quality
experience
Reproduction
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Bangladesh
  • Doctor-patient discourse
  • Language and cognition
  • Semiotics
  • Social construction of illness

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Anthropology
  • Social Sciences (miscellaneous)
  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

Cite this

Discourse, Power, and the Diagnosis of Weakness : Encountering Practitioners in Bangladesh. / Wilce Jr, James M.

In: Medical Anthropology Quarterly, Vol. 11, No. 3, 1997, p. 352-374.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f5bf6ac7b44a43a398273234bd01f87c,
title = "Discourse, Power, and the Diagnosis of Weakness: Encountering Practitioners in Bangladesh",
abstract = "The author's experiences as a {"}patient{"} of nonbiomedical practitioners, and an examination of Bangladeshis' encounters with practitioners (dāktārs [biomedical doctors], herbalists, exorcists, and diviners), reveal the interactive means by which the diagnosis of durbalatā (weakness) is constructed. In the cases presented, facing power in the person of the practitioner means losing face. I argue that discursive phenomena above and below the lexical level are responsible. The phenomena described - (1) interruption or dismissal of the patient's words by practitioners and others present during the clinical encounter, (2) divinatory routines that assign the durbalatā label to women, and (3) one patient's use of {"}reaky{"} voice quality in a strictly {"}popular sector{"} (domestic) encounter - are nonreferential but socially significant semiotic processes that operate, for the most part, beneath the level of discursive awareness. These encounters and their outcomes have more to do with social reproduction than with any unambiguously effective therapeutic outcome.",
keywords = "Bangladesh, Doctor-patient discourse, Language and cognition, Semiotics, Social construction of illness",
author = "{Wilce Jr}, {James M}",
year = "1997",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "11",
pages = "352--374",
journal = "Medical Anthropology Quarterly",
issn = "0745-5194",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Discourse, Power, and the Diagnosis of Weakness

T2 - Encountering Practitioners in Bangladesh

AU - Wilce Jr, James M

PY - 1997

Y1 - 1997

N2 - The author's experiences as a "patient" of nonbiomedical practitioners, and an examination of Bangladeshis' encounters with practitioners (dāktārs [biomedical doctors], herbalists, exorcists, and diviners), reveal the interactive means by which the diagnosis of durbalatā (weakness) is constructed. In the cases presented, facing power in the person of the practitioner means losing face. I argue that discursive phenomena above and below the lexical level are responsible. The phenomena described - (1) interruption or dismissal of the patient's words by practitioners and others present during the clinical encounter, (2) divinatory routines that assign the durbalatā label to women, and (3) one patient's use of "reaky" voice quality in a strictly "popular sector" (domestic) encounter - are nonreferential but socially significant semiotic processes that operate, for the most part, beneath the level of discursive awareness. These encounters and their outcomes have more to do with social reproduction than with any unambiguously effective therapeutic outcome.

AB - The author's experiences as a "patient" of nonbiomedical practitioners, and an examination of Bangladeshis' encounters with practitioners (dāktārs [biomedical doctors], herbalists, exorcists, and diviners), reveal the interactive means by which the diagnosis of durbalatā (weakness) is constructed. In the cases presented, facing power in the person of the practitioner means losing face. I argue that discursive phenomena above and below the lexical level are responsible. The phenomena described - (1) interruption or dismissal of the patient's words by practitioners and others present during the clinical encounter, (2) divinatory routines that assign the durbalatā label to women, and (3) one patient's use of "reaky" voice quality in a strictly "popular sector" (domestic) encounter - are nonreferential but socially significant semiotic processes that operate, for the most part, beneath the level of discursive awareness. These encounters and their outcomes have more to do with social reproduction than with any unambiguously effective therapeutic outcome.

KW - Bangladesh

KW - Doctor-patient discourse

KW - Language and cognition

KW - Semiotics

KW - Social construction of illness

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0031226128&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0031226128&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 11

SP - 352

EP - 374

JO - Medical Anthropology Quarterly

JF - Medical Anthropology Quarterly

SN - 0745-5194

IS - 3

ER -