Differential Earnings Behavior and the Security Market Assessment of Variation in Seasonal Earnings Patterns

Allen W. Bathke, Kenneth S Lorek, G. Lee Willinger

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We provide new evidence regarding the anomalous security market behavior that pertains to the predictability of abnormal security returns at future quarterly earnings announcements (Bernard and Thomas [1990]) as well as the security market’s ability to form quarterly earnings expectations that are consistent with the market factoring in the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series (Ball and Bartov [1996]; Soffer and Lys [1999]). Consistent with extant work, we find that just prior to the quarterly earnings announcement date, the security market’s expectation of quarterly earnings is consistent with the market recognizing the serial correlation in seasonally differenced quarterly earnings but underestimating its magnitude. When we treat all firms as exhibiting the same quarterly earnings process, our results reinforce the findings of Soffer and Lys (1999) that security market earnings expectations at the beginning of the quarter are consistent with investors not recognizing the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. By distinguishing between those firms whose quarterly earnings process is inconsistent with a seasonal random walk (SRW) process (i.e., “bad-fit” firms) vis-à-vis those firms whose quarterly earnings process is better described by the SRW process (i.e., “good-fit” firms), we provide additional insights on this relationship throughout the quarter leading up to the quarterly earnings announcement date. Specifically, we find that security market expectations of quarterly earnings are consistent with a market that recognizes the differential time-series properties of quarterly earnings. That is, at the beginning of the quarter, for the “bad-fit” (“good-fit”) firms, we find that the security market acts as if it is aware (unaware) of the correct sign of the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. However, the security market still acts as if it underestimates the magnitude of the serial correlation.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)463-482
Number of pages20
JournalJournal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance
Volume19
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - 2004

Fingerprint

Securities market
Earnings differentials
Serial correlation
Earnings announcements
Random walk
Predictability
Market behavior
Security returns
Factoring
Investors

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Accounting
  • Finance
  • Economics, Econometrics and Finance (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Differential Earnings Behavior and the Security Market Assessment of Variation in Seasonal Earnings Patterns. / Bathke, Allen W.; Lorek, Kenneth S; Willinger, G. Lee.

In: Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance, Vol. 19, No. 4, 2004, p. 463-482.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

@article{0543cf7b88d84beca98ec0cc140adaab,
title = "Differential Earnings Behavior and the Security Market Assessment of Variation in Seasonal Earnings Patterns",
abstract = "We provide new evidence regarding the anomalous security market behavior that pertains to the predictability of abnormal security returns at future quarterly earnings announcements (Bernard and Thomas [1990]) as well as the security market’s ability to form quarterly earnings expectations that are consistent with the market factoring in the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series (Ball and Bartov [1996]; Soffer and Lys [1999]). Consistent with extant work, we find that just prior to the quarterly earnings announcement date, the security market’s expectation of quarterly earnings is consistent with the market recognizing the serial correlation in seasonally differenced quarterly earnings but underestimating its magnitude. When we treat all firms as exhibiting the same quarterly earnings process, our results reinforce the findings of Soffer and Lys (1999) that security market earnings expectations at the beginning of the quarter are consistent with investors not recognizing the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. By distinguishing between those firms whose quarterly earnings process is inconsistent with a seasonal random walk (SRW) process (i.e., “bad-fit” firms) vis-{\`a}-vis those firms whose quarterly earnings process is better described by the SRW process (i.e., “good-fit” firms), we provide additional insights on this relationship throughout the quarter leading up to the quarterly earnings announcement date. Specifically, we find that security market expectations of quarterly earnings are consistent with a market that recognizes the differential time-series properties of quarterly earnings. That is, at the beginning of the quarter, for the “bad-fit” (“good-fit”) firms, we find that the security market acts as if it is aware (unaware) of the correct sign of the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. However, the security market still acts as if it underestimates the magnitude of the serial correlation.",
author = "Bathke, {Allen W.} and Lorek, {Kenneth S} and Willinger, {G. Lee}",
year = "2004",
doi = "10.1177/0148558X0401900407",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "19",
pages = "463--482",
journal = "Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance",
issn = "0148-558X",
publisher = "Greenwood Publishing Group Inc.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Differential Earnings Behavior and the Security Market Assessment of Variation in Seasonal Earnings Patterns

AU - Bathke, Allen W.

AU - Lorek, Kenneth S

AU - Willinger, G. Lee

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - We provide new evidence regarding the anomalous security market behavior that pertains to the predictability of abnormal security returns at future quarterly earnings announcements (Bernard and Thomas [1990]) as well as the security market’s ability to form quarterly earnings expectations that are consistent with the market factoring in the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series (Ball and Bartov [1996]; Soffer and Lys [1999]). Consistent with extant work, we find that just prior to the quarterly earnings announcement date, the security market’s expectation of quarterly earnings is consistent with the market recognizing the serial correlation in seasonally differenced quarterly earnings but underestimating its magnitude. When we treat all firms as exhibiting the same quarterly earnings process, our results reinforce the findings of Soffer and Lys (1999) that security market earnings expectations at the beginning of the quarter are consistent with investors not recognizing the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. By distinguishing between those firms whose quarterly earnings process is inconsistent with a seasonal random walk (SRW) process (i.e., “bad-fit” firms) vis-à-vis those firms whose quarterly earnings process is better described by the SRW process (i.e., “good-fit” firms), we provide additional insights on this relationship throughout the quarter leading up to the quarterly earnings announcement date. Specifically, we find that security market expectations of quarterly earnings are consistent with a market that recognizes the differential time-series properties of quarterly earnings. That is, at the beginning of the quarter, for the “bad-fit” (“good-fit”) firms, we find that the security market acts as if it is aware (unaware) of the correct sign of the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. However, the security market still acts as if it underestimates the magnitude of the serial correlation.

AB - We provide new evidence regarding the anomalous security market behavior that pertains to the predictability of abnormal security returns at future quarterly earnings announcements (Bernard and Thomas [1990]) as well as the security market’s ability to form quarterly earnings expectations that are consistent with the market factoring in the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series (Ball and Bartov [1996]; Soffer and Lys [1999]). Consistent with extant work, we find that just prior to the quarterly earnings announcement date, the security market’s expectation of quarterly earnings is consistent with the market recognizing the serial correlation in seasonally differenced quarterly earnings but underestimating its magnitude. When we treat all firms as exhibiting the same quarterly earnings process, our results reinforce the findings of Soffer and Lys (1999) that security market earnings expectations at the beginning of the quarter are consistent with investors not recognizing the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. By distinguishing between those firms whose quarterly earnings process is inconsistent with a seasonal random walk (SRW) process (i.e., “bad-fit” firms) vis-à-vis those firms whose quarterly earnings process is better described by the SRW process (i.e., “good-fit” firms), we provide additional insights on this relationship throughout the quarter leading up to the quarterly earnings announcement date. Specifically, we find that security market expectations of quarterly earnings are consistent with a market that recognizes the differential time-series properties of quarterly earnings. That is, at the beginning of the quarter, for the “bad-fit” (“good-fit”) firms, we find that the security market acts as if it is aware (unaware) of the correct sign of the serial correlation in the seasonally differenced quarterly earnings series. However, the security market still acts as if it underestimates the magnitude of the serial correlation.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84990397467&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84990397467&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0148558X0401900407

DO - 10.1177/0148558X0401900407

M3 - Review article

VL - 19

SP - 463

EP - 482

JO - Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance

JF - Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance

SN - 0148-558X

IS - 4

ER -